Fairytale hunters find it Grimm up north

Image by Kieran Wilkinson

Image by Kieran Wilkinson

Bradford City 2

Leigh 61, McMahon 76 (pen)

Aldershot Town 0

Wednesday 18 November, 2015

By Phil Abbott

Fairytales are meant to have a ‘happily ever after’ ending. Unfortunately for a plucky Aldershot Town team at Valley Parade tonight – and rather happily for Bradford City – this is a tale they won’t be telling too often in the future. It’s not a tale with much to tell in truth – some parts of the game reflecting the dismal weather.

Returning from their excellent home draw with the Bantams once upon a time (well, last week), the Shots came into the return match full of confidence and belief. As the second chapter of their 1st round story wrote itself on a blustery, wet Valley Parade evening, it soon became clear that the front-foot action they served up on home soil just over a week ago would not be re-kindled in front of the BT Sport cameras.

In a first half that failed to warm the extremities of the sparse Valley Parade crowd, City struggled to find any rhythm. A combination of difficult weather conditions, sloppy passing and a dogged Aldershot defensive effort meant that the Bantams rarely found second gear. A 12-2 half-time free kick count in City’s favour could have been even more but for a string of sensible advantages played by the referee. City were beginning to get frustrated by the niggles.

The tone of the half was set within the first 20 seconds of the game as Devante Cole shot wildly over from 15 yards, whilst seeing the offside flag raised in synchronised fashion. As if to match Cole, in the 6th minute Richard Brodie had an equally wayward shot blaze into the Kop. If this had been the first page of a Grimm tale, if we’re being honest, many would have been forgiven for closing the book at this stage.

However, determined to make their mark, it was Aldershot who created the first decent chance of the half with another Brodie strike, this time of sufficient quality to force Ben Williams into a good save low to his right. Williams parried well and the danger was averted.

Devante Cole’s pace was causing some concern in the Aldershot back ranks and when he beautifully controlled a searching ball on the edge of the box, he saw his low shot blocked by Bantams’ Old Boy Luke Oliver.  Strained shouts for a penalty as the ball deflected onto the arm of an onrushing defender were short-lived; ball to hand.

During the middle third of the first half, City winger Mark Marshall emerged as the main Bradford City threat, as he forced two saves from Shots stopper Phil Smith; one pushed onto the post with a fine save, only for the rebound to evade James Hanson who was steaming into the box.

Frustration began to build as City gave too much possession away and Aldershot grew in confidence. Happily for the Bantams, the southerners failed to find the back of the net during their best period of pressure which followed, and the teams played out a goalless first half.

Whatever instructions Phil Parkinson’s insistent team-talk contained, they took time to materialise in the 2nd half following the stop-start opening exchanges. Even after Nathan Clarke had headed narrowly wide from a corner and Tony McMahon had shot over from distance, City were still struggling to make the unfolding story one of interest. When Walker wastefully shot over from a good position, City were finally shaken into life. As the rain fell with greater intensity, so upped the Bantam’s work-rate.

But the Bantams game-plan suffered a blow when James Hanson sustained an ankle injury in the 56th minute and was forced to leave the field. This soon revealed itself as somewhat of a blessing in disguise. With the introduction of Billy Clarke, City soon turned to a fresh page and began to create a more noteworthy approach, being forced to ditch the long-ball tactics and play the ball to feet.

Within minutes, the highlight of the evening saw City take the lead. A perfectly timed cross-field ball from the busy Billy Knott found Greg Leigh with plenty to do. He played his first touch in front, and used his pace to glide into the area and slot sublimely beyond the helpless, advancing Smith in the Aldershot goal, with a classy chip shot. It was an effort that would have graced many more deserving games than this one, and the moment of brilliance that City needed to ultimately shake off their tenacious visitors.

City had seized full control and only four minutes after replacing Devante Cole, substitute Luke James effectively closed the book on the plucky Shots. His persistence and direct running won a disputed penalty after Omar Beckles was drawn into a tired tackle on the edge of the six yard box. Despite the impressive Smith getting a hand to Tony McMahon’s fiercely struck spot-kick, he couldn’t stop it registering and cementing City’s place in the 2nd round.

Marshall and McMahon continued to trouble a tiring and deflated Aldershot team in the closing 10 minutes and closed out the victory with considerable comfort.

It was not much to write about. City have another home game in round two against non-league opposition and will expect chapter two to have a similar outcome, even though nothing is taken for granted in the land of fairytales. For Aldershot, their dream is over, for City, theirs are on the horizon, perhaps…

Now. Sleep tight, because it’s Chesham United next.

City: Williams, Darby, McArdle, N Clarke, Leigh, McMahon, Liddle (Routis 81), Knott, Marshall, Hanson (B Clarke 59), Cole (James 70)

Not used: Cracknell, Morris, Reid, Mottley-Henry

Categories: Match Reviews

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

6 replies

  1. We did what we had to do and thats all you can ask in cups especially against lower league teams.

    If rumours are true that Meredith is been scouted by various Championship clubs including Brighton then I have no problem keeping Greg Leigh in the side permanently who I think needs a little work on his defence but he causes much more of an attacking threat and scores goals.

    The more games he plays for us the better he will become and if he keeps up these performances he will surely be a Championship player too

  2. A spot on report, the Shots came close a couple of times and City weren’t at their fluent best but they were focused and up for it enough to stop me from ever really worrying about an upset.

    My first time really watching Leigh and I’ve got to say I was impressed. I’m a huge Meredith fan but He’s certainly got strong competition for his starting spot

  3. The biggest positive I take from last night is that such a great piece of skill was from our second choice left back, it shows how far the squad has come.

  4. Is it only me that is concerned about our team at the moment? I appreciate that we have gone five consecutive games without conceding a goal and part of that is due to Ben Williams so credit to him after people were calling for him to be dropped the minute that we signed Brad Jones.

    However, I am concerned about Nathan Clarke. I thought that he looked shaky at times last night and it’s not ideal playing two right footed centre backs. I hope that Clarke can put in some better performances during his Bradford City career. Let’s see how he performs against Paddy Madden this weekend.

    And so to our right side of midfield. I have nothing against Tony McMahon but he is not a right winger and we need more creativity in our team so please can we see Morris (now that he is fit) or Motley-Henry play on the right side of midfield.

    Last night, for the first hour, I thought that we struggled against a team two divisions below us. But credit to the team for gaining the victory and avoiding a potential banana skin. What a superb pass from Billy Knott which led to Greg Leigh’s well taken goal.

    Finally, a nice touch from James Hanson when shaking hands with the Aldershot Town players prior to kick off, he had an additional tap on the top of Luke Oliver’s arm as if to say welcome back to Valley Parade.

    • Although I am not entirely confident with Nathan Clarke at centre half what is the issue with having two right footed centred back as the majority of teams do – Andrew Davies was and Reece Burke (although very competent with both) is.

      I also don’t understand the constant calling for Mottley-Henry to be put in. None of us know how good he is and PP obviously doesn’t think he’s ready. Tony Mcmahon has been involved in the majority of our goals recently and his distribution from set pieces has been pivotal to our upturn in form. The team seems very well balanced and the only concern is the lack of clear goal scoring opportunities being created. That will come though.

      • Ironic Luke that you say that the only concern is the lack of clear goal scoring opportunities being created. That is a concern of mine too. I agree that McMahon has created quite a few goals from set pieces this season.

        However, I feel that we aren’t playing exciting football this season. Take out the loanees of Reid and Burke and we are a weaker team.

        Hanson has fed off scraps this season, being made a scapegoat for us playing the long ball game and is still our joint top scorer this season. Hanson is at his most effective when we play two out and out wingers.

        I am pro-Parkinson and have posted many supportive comments on this website but at the moment, despite our position in the league, like I said earlier this week I am concerned about how we are playing at the moment.

%d bloggers like this: