By Tim Penfold
The topic of conversation this week has been inevitable from the moment the fixture list came out. On Twitter, on the forums and on this website, it’s all been about Phil Parkinson, and the reaction is, at best, mixed. He left abruptly this summer, putting back City’s preparations by several weeks, and there has been much debate on what he left behind.
One of the things he left was eight contracted players. This was a consequence of the short-term nature of both his management and the boardroom strategy in place, but has also led to some frustration that contracts were not sorted earlier – this definitely cost us Ben Williams, while the decision not to take up the option on Billy Knott was sensible while Parkinson was manager but has cost us a player who may have fitted in to McCall’s tactical plans a little better.
That said, if you look at what was left behind, it contains the core of Parkinson’s side – the inner circle, as it were. The players who Phil Parkinson fully trusted, and who have responded well under Stuart McCall as well. In several interviews McCall has stated how impressed he is with the standard of training. This was something that Phil Parkinson prioritised, and the players that he left behind are helping to keep these standards up.
The short-termism of his management also led to the youth team being neglected. With the exception of Oli McBurnie, who was promoted a little bit too soon despite his potential, Phil Parkinson didn’t bring many players through, and the contrast with Danny Devine’s emergence under McCall is obvious. It’s also a source of frustration that three academy graduates have, after release, moved on to similar or bigger clubs on frees.
Again, this was in part because Parkinson was asked to prioritise results and short-term performance over long term development – this is no different to many Premier League teams, and is a major reason why young homegrown players don’t get first team opportunities. It would’ve been interesting to see what Parkinson would’ve done with the funding from the new board in place, but it is notable that at his other clubs (with the exception of his short spell at Hull) he has successfully brought through young players.
The frustration with the way he left has also led people to downplay his achievements at the club. It’s easy to forget how poor a situation we were in at the time – a squad lacking in quality, and a summer where finances were so poor that we came closer than many realised to administration and a move to Odsal. This was after years and years of decline, when club heroes and proven managers had failed to turn the club around.
Financially, this club is now on the best footing it has been for years, but without the success on the pitch and the headlines that followed, would our new German investors have been interested? Or would we still be scraping from season to season, scrambling around at the bottom of League Two, cheap tickets scrapped as crowds continued to fall?
In terms of league performance, he achieved his objective every single year. He kept us up, he got us up, stabilised us in the division above and got us two games away from promotion last season. The football may have been more functional than flowing, but when was the last time Bradford City had such sustained success? And that’s without even mentioning the remarkable cup runs, which brought us to the attention of the world in a way that not even our time in the Premier League managed.
It’s this success which has meant that Valley Parade is no longer half-empty, no longer turns on the team after half an hour. It’s this success that has brought fans back to the club or brought new people in – of the people I sit with in the Kop, one’s first game was against Arsenal, and one’s first game in a decade was against Aston Villa. It’s this success that has given me my best memories in football.
Because this is the real legacy of Phil Parkinson. He made the world sit up and notice Bradford City on so many occasions. It was his team that made history with the League Cup run – a feat that has only been done three other times in the history of world football. It was his team that dragged the world’s media to Bradford, his team that got Width of a Post on Newsnight, his team that drew huge crowds to the open top bus parade, his team invited to Sports Personality of the Year. And it was his team that, two years later, did it all again at Stamford Bridge.
And that is going to be the defining memory that I have of Phil Parkinson’s teams – shouting myself hoarse, hugging both friends and complete strangers in disbelief and joy as we took on the best teams in the country.
If you like what Width of a Post do, please vote for us in the Football Blogging Awards.
For me the good out weighs the bad. Up to now Parky is also be my 2nd fave manager behind Paul Jewell (if successful Stuart might overtake him).
I didn’t like the way we left but that doesn’t mean I’m going to slag him off at every opportunity.
The times we had were great but he’s now on the opposite team so now he will be treated like every other manager against us.
Im going to concentrate on supporting the team and not making this about PP. Its about Bradford vs Bolton and I hope we win the bragging rights come 5.00 Saturday
I think people are clutching at straws to find reasons to beat PP because he is no longer ours and there is a bitterness there. Not that I’m trying to get at this article as it is well balanced but there are two examples I would question. Yes Billy Knott may have been more suited to his team and I loved Billy, but really would he have even got on the bench in this squad when all are fit?
Yes Stuart gave a chance to Devine but only because of awful bad luck with injuries – similar to when McBurnie got the call up. Difference being Devine was ready and has flourished where McBurnie didn’t.
I have no problems with the state he left the team in – imagine had he started signing up players like Knott then would Stuart have been able to go out and get Vincelot?
The only reason that he’s lost a bit of the sparkle in my eyes is his attitude since. No thanks to the fans, even today in the T&A it has a sense of arrogance about it. The reason that the likes of Stuart, Lawrence, Jewell etc are held in such high esteem is because Bradford City’s love for them is returned in the same way. In years to come will we see Parky return for Golf Days? It is that reason that I’ll be very appreciative to him for turning this club around and the memories he gave us and will always offer him a good reception because of it but my fondness for him specifically won’t match that of Mccall, Windass, Beagrie, Jewell, Lawrence, Wethers, Gary Jones etc.
We should clap him when he comes out then let’s forget it and concentrate on getting 3 points.
My first game was in 1962 and believe me I’ve seen everything: Here is some perspective for what its worth:
Many years of the Avenue derbies – great times and great rivalry.
1968/9 Bruce Bannister scoring at Darlington away 1969 – me and my Dad getting on the wrong bus coming home and didn’t give a jot.
1982 I think Bobbys equaliser against Bournemouth at home.
1984/5 Derby and Brentford at home, Cambridge and Bolton away and 5 days later trauma on a scale only my Grandad and people like him could even begin understand (at the Somme).
Hereford at home and Swansea at home (Gary Shaw hat-trick in 4 minutes for Swansea), cannot remember the years, just the desperation of the games and my mood for days.
1998/9 – Barnsley at Home, Huddersfield, QPR and Wolves away.
2 seasons in the Premier League – Middlesborough and Sunderland away and Liverpool at home.
Last 5 years – Wigan, Arsenal, Villa over 2 legs, Wembley Cup final (10,000-1 odds), Northampton, Chelsea, Sunderland, five years of continuous improvement in league position.
We all need to thank the Board, Parky and all of the staff and players for the last 5 years and be gracious enough to accept that things change and its the cut and thrust, the roller coaster, the if-only’s, the why didn’t we’s, the shocks, the delights, the tears and the joy that make us love this ruddy game and this club anyway. We are far greater surely than to cast spite on someone at any time in our past who served us all so well.
Here’s to the next 5 years.
It comes down to a divorce really. A revered manager who looks like he’s settled for the long term shocks us by suddenly leaving us for someone else. But his legacy is pride restored. I won’t be at Bolton but i’ll stand & applaud when he comes to VP. But it’s McCall’s Bradford Army now.