
| Chesterfield 3 |
| Metcalfe 45+2, Grigg 71, Mandeville 90+2 |
| Bradford City 3 |
| Pointon 10, Sarcevic 19 pen, Pattison 49 |
By Adam Raj
This was never going to be easy. But even by the standards of Bradford City, the tensions are reaching unbearable levels.
Make no mistake, City were largely excellent today. First half especially, they looked every inch a side on the way to promotion, just as they had done in the opening moments at Swindon.
They should’ve been one up within the first few minutes, Calum Kavanagh found himself in behind the Chesterfield back line and squared to Alex Pattison whose shot was tame and straight at Ryan Boot. It wasn’t the best pass from Kavanagh but City’s stand in skipper really should’ve buried it.
But that was a sign of things to come. City were so full of energy and pace in that first half, Chesterfield couldn’t lay a glove on them. The press was suffocating the home side into making mistake after mistake and the Bantams smelt blood.
Ten minutes in and City had their rewards. Kavanagh produced a neat flick to set Pattison away to drive towards the box. Pattison produced the right pass and fed Bobby Pointon who slotted in off the post under the outstretched challenge from Ash Palmer.
City continued to play with an intensity that saw them get in behind Chesterfield time and time again. Kavanagh’s pace was causing all sorts of problems for a defence that was less than mobile. Pattison and Brandon Khela were having excellent games – so sharp and alive to everything, the hosts’ ageing midfield of John Fleck and Tom Naylor couldn’t live with them and were second to every ball.
Nine minutes later and City doubled their lead. Pointon’s corner flew past everyone but Naylor was a little too keen to stop Antoni Sarcevic from picking up the loose ball and pulled the City number ten to the floor. City had what was a rare spot kick and Sarcevic made no mistake, lashing the ball straight down the middle.
City were well worth their two goal lead and the only negative is it wasn’t more.
But then comes stoppage time…
City have unearthed an uncanny knack of shooting themselves in the foot on their travels recently. Two goals to the good at Swindon last time out and City fail to see the game through to the break with their margin of lead in tact. Nine days later and it happened again. Michael Olakigbe was wrong side of Tayo Adaramola and Jack Shepherd, he cut it back for Jenson Metcalfe who swept in off of the far post. Suddenly it was 1-2 in a game City had absolutely dominated.
“The timings of the goals are absolutely murdering us” Graham Alexander bemoaned afterwards. And he’s right. City needed to see that half out to nil with a professional ending, something it looks like they’ve forgotten how to do.
Thankfully, the damage was erased almost instantly as the game resumed. Pointon did well to rob Metcalfe on halfway and played a ball up the line to Kavanagh who got in behind again. Adaramola was bursting forward on the underlap and was played in perfectly by Kavanagh before lifting an inch perfect ball for Pattison to head home with a fabulous effort.
1-3 and nothing more than the Bantams deserved.
But shortly after came the turning point. Khela was replaced by Jamie Walker in what was a substitution that confused everyone in claret and amber. Whilst it had been a terrific team performance, Khela and Pattison had been the heartbeat and the catalyst for everything that had been so successful. That substitution disrupted that flow more than Alexander could’ve imagined.
Sarcevic replaced Khela in the deeper role but could not get to grips with the intricacies of City’s press in that area. Not only that, but we lost everything that Sarcevic had been doing well further up the pitch.
Chesterfield suddenly got back into it. They were finding more space in between the lines, they were playing through the press much more successfully and working opportunities to put dangerous balls into the box.
The change, according to Alexander, was down to Khela feeling unwell at half time, so the knives that were well and truly out for him at full time are put away for now.
71 minutes on the clock and the hosts pulled one back. Metcalfe broke the lines and played Will Grigg in behind Aden Baldwin. The striker rounded Sam Walker and had an easy finish into an open net.
Further enforced changed lead to Romoney Critchlow becoming Pattison’s third partner of the day and the last of City’s control in that area quickly evaporated.
City had stopped doing everything that worked so well and were not doing the one thing that they should’ve been.
Alexander’s post match comments criticised the decision making and game management from the lesser experienced players in the squad.
Putting it bluntly, there was no game management. We see it most weeks at Valley Parade, teams manage to run the clock down with absolute ease, ten men behind the ball and frustrate the life out of us.
We have not got this about us. We’re not nasty enough when it matters and don’t understand the context of games where that sort of behaviour is a necessity.
It’s the reason we threw it away at Swindon and it’s the reason we threw another two points away this afternoon.
93 minutes on the clock today and Liam Mandeville was afforded the time and space to spin and fire his shot home from ten yards out.
I felt sick. Twice in a week, City have managed to shoot themselves in the foot and rob themselves of five points. They have thrown away a two goal lead four times over those two games.
And it was all so preventable. The substitutions will receive the attention, no doubt but the players on the pitch have got to manage the game better, much better. To do this twice in three games with this much on the line is bordering on unforgivable. It was only thanks to even more dropped points by Walsall that City remain in an automatic promotion place.
Amazingly, City are still only three points off top spot with a game at leaders Doncaster to follow on Saturday. A repeat for the first hour today and City have every chance of a positive result, but under no circumstances can they afford to ‘manage’ a game in the way they have done lately. This cannot be repeated for a third time.

Categories: Match Reviews
Another brilliant Bradford City home win gives more licence to dream the unmentionable
Bradford City make it back to back wins as they avoid a banana skin in Devon
A night to forget, a January of change: Bradford City’s squad reckoning
A return to winning ways, though Bradford City are still labouring to rediscover the higher gears
WHy, why,why!!!!
Are we a team of BOTTLE JOBS? Or can we scrape and crawl our way over the line?
I honestly have No idea.
MANAGER AND TEAM GIVE ME HOPE!!
OVER TO YOU
Good article it sums everything up perfectly.
Too many missed chances and a lack of composure under pressure. We wilted again after such a promising start. Taking Khela off lost us the midfield. He still looked full of energy to me. I’m a big fan of GA but he definitely got it badly wrong yesterday.
It had a feeling of inevitably they would equalise.
I don’t know why we can’t hold a lead. Crappy teams like Tranmere at home or Accrington away can keep us at arms length seemingly easily. How hard can it be?
I’ve been very optimistic about our chances of promotion and have had a pop at a few people on here for getting their knickers in a twist when things haven’t gone well but I’m struggling to keep my spirits up after the last three games. I don’t fancy our chances at Doncaster next Saturday, I think we could be on to a hiding. They’ve got Sharpe back from his suspension, he’ll be well rested and raring to go. McCann will have them fired up. It’s another game where we’re going to badly miss Smallwood.
Thanks Adan – excellent report in tough circumstances !
The chain of events from Smallwood’s sending off sees City gain two points from a possible nine, concede nine goals, squander two goal leads four times and concede goals in injury time four times. (All the more frustrating yesterday because here our two goal leads were thoroughly deserved through excellent attacking play, unlike the gifts from Swindon.)
I am afraId I am more critical of Alexander than you are Adam. He seems to have learnt nothing from the Swindon debacle and resorts to blaming ‘less experienced players’ . Take a good look yourself Graham and your decision making.
And what do these games do to the confidence of even the more experienced players ?Supposing we’re in the second leg of the play-offs, 2-1 up with 30 minutes to go…..I don’t want to go there.
More immediately it’s Donny….with Sharpe back. Perhaps if we’re four up at half-time we can see out a draw.
I don’t even know where to start regarding yesterday. The immense frustration at the fact that we looked absolutely brilliant for the first 30 minutes or so and scored two fantastic open play goals just to throw it away all over again.
The substitutions were a killer again but in fairness to GA, the defence has crumbled in both of those last two away games. There’s no way with the personnel that we’ve had on the field for both that we should have thrown away multiple two goal leads over and over, and even though the changes and tactical set up have played a role in that, those lads at the back need to take a real hard look at themselves just as much as GA should.
This season has been so tough to watch in regards of not being able to marry up our form. The contrast between home and away scorelines has been brutal and before when we were able to rely on solid defending to get over the line when we couldn’t score, now we can’t even win when we net 3-4 times in a match.
Donny is going to be as tough as it gets but my only hope is that we produce a similar performance early on and they’re the ones who crumble under the pressure this time around. If not, we’ll be heading into the final day in 4th spot and praying for results to go our way, because even though they’ve been awful for months, I just can’t see any way in which Walsall don’t get a result out of Accrington at home..
I’m sorry to say it, but the defence has started leaking goals ever since Byrne came back into the team. I’d be starting Baldwin, Shephard and Critchlow on Saturday.
Or Huntington – but definitely not Byrne.
I’m more willing than others to give Alexander the benefit of the doubt. He disclosed a couple of weeks ago that there was a sickness bug going round the squad- it may be linked to that. I don’t know Khela’s family set up, but a number of the squad have got young families, and I remember when we went through that time, we often picked up bugs from them.
Following the near crippling injury problems earlier in the season, he is also carefully managing the game time of players vulnerable to recurring injuries, like Sarcovic. I decided in January that we finally had a squad fully capable of achieving promotion, but getting there would come down to the wild cards of injury and available players.
i think Alexander has made the occasional misjudgement- such as bringing on 2 defensive subs at Swindon t half time- I expected one. But overall, I think he’s doing a decent job of juggling what he’s got. He’s not at fault when the cards in his hand suddenly weaken.
All good points Andy.
It’s perhaps telling that our bench seems weaker the closer we’ve got to the business end of the season.
Yes, too many defensive substitutions have cost us in recent weeks. But they’ve been made perhaps because neither of the attacking options signed in January – Mellon or Leigh – have contributed anything useful when it’s mattered in the last few games.
GA obviously doesn’t trust them to make an impact – Mellon because he’s less effective in the press, and Leigh because (as yesterday proved) he can’t be relied on to find the net when one-on-one with the keeper.
Thankfully Kav had been bang at it in that period, but when he tires after 70 mins of constant pressing we just don’t have another option up top.
GA states we shot ourselves in the foot! 2 of Chesterfield goals scored in injury time in both half’s. Khela according to GA was ill and that’s why he substituted him but rearranging his tactics forced Sascevic was forced to play in a different position that didn’t suit him and he became less effective. GA did this against Swindon, Notts County and now Chesterfeild! All affected City’s performance. Conceding goals in injury time in two of the last 3 matches has cost us 4 points. These mistakes could lose us a an immediate promotion spot. I would have taken a draw at Chesterfield but the equaliser in the last minute was hard to take. A win against Fleetwood is a must. No pressure!
Aaaaaaaaarrrggggghhhhhhh! Ghfhsjjfhhsjijtjjsh!! F******kkkk!
Nothing further to add.
A Sending off and bizarre substitutions in the last 3 ganes have cost us an automatic promotion place in my opinion. We’d need to be 3-0 up at Donny by halftime to get anything from that game.
I’m a fan of GA too. He has given us this team, and for the most part, we’ve seen entertaining football and a return to VP being a fortress again. As we all know, success hasn’t exactly been flowing at City over the past seven years, so being in the top three and walking away from a Saturday 3pm with a spring in your step is a brilliant feeling.That said, like everyone, I do have to question his substitutions in this game. Of course, GA and his coaching team have access to information we don’t and to a degree, you have to trust their judgment.
But playing defenders in midfield, especially when they haven’t featured there before, is difficult to justify. Not when you’ve got players on the bench with the character, experience and skill set to step into those roles.
Lapslie should have come on instead of Crichlow to help manage the game and take the sting out of what looked like increasingly confident opposition. It’s a strange decision at this stage of the season to start experimenting with players out of position and ultimately, the responsibility lies with GA and his staff.
Let’s hope we show up at Doncaster and don’t repeat the performance from Port Vale away. Come on City!
Great report Adam, although I’m utterly beyond analysis at this point.
What should be an exciting time for us all, well, it just isn’t is it?
I woke up this morning and my first thought was, ‘I wonder which emotionally punishing way we’ll lose to Donny on Saturday”.
They are going to blow this aren’t they….
We should be home and dry by now and just wondering if we will get the championship or not.
Hope its not history repeating itself. City fans of a certain vintage remember the “nearly season” Hendrie sent off at Man City cost us promotion to the Division One in the late 80’s, failed in the play offs afterwards and then McCall & Hendrie sold…
If (or when) this fails, do you believe that GA is the man to continue at VP in L2 next season? Serious question.
A definite yes for me. On win ratio, he’s up there in the top few across the whole club history, after a decent number of matches.
And as I’ve commented before, his approach and values are a good fit for us.
Maybe in his absence people will appreciate how much Smallwood does for the side. Organising, tackling, encouraging, positioning et etc…
To some extent, Steve, but we’ve only taken nine points from the last nine games, and Smallwood has only been suspended for the last two.
Until we had to take Khela off and subsequently started to dramatically lose our shape. I thought our midfield was more mobile and effective than it had been for a long time.
This is the season that keeps on giving! It would be so dull to have everything settled several games ago. Imagine if we’d carried on winning every game 1-0… Bo-ring! Just two games to go and we can easily finish first or fourth.
Honestly though I’m feeling surprisingly positive, while it’s frustrating to lose two-goal leads, twice, our Smallwood-free games could have gone much, much worse than this, especially if other results had gone against us. The new midfield duo looks a little bit superb so far, Sarcevic is back and looks dangerous, Kavanagh seems to have found a new level to his linkup play, and the whole team looks really good going forward.
We have every chance of beating Doncaster and setting up a last day of the season to beat all others, with three or four teams in a wild final-day shoot-out. Or we could lose 6-5 to Donny to three injury time goals and sink back down into the playoffs and the likelihood of neverending league two chaosball again next season. I have no idea what to expect. Thank you Bradford City AFC
Agree entirely with this.
We wouldn’t be football fans if there wasn’t the twist, turns, drama, the potential for it to all fall apart. This is all I ask for at the beginning of the season and I won’t complain now it’s here! That is what makes it the greatest sport and what is just missing from the elite level.
I do think this year could have been the first season we walked a league title but for the injuries. Yesterday was a joy to watch for 60 mins. We showed how good we are as we have in other spells with the box midfield and Patto and Sauce being available. You won’t find a bigger advocate than Smallwood for me, but we still win that game comfortably if Khela doesn’t have to go off. Injuries are 1 thing but appendicitis and illness ultimately being our downfall is hard to swallow.
Hopefully Khela shakes off the illness and Patto and Sarce are good to go again for another huge game.
Whatever the story of illness and subs we simply missed too many good opportunities. We had several breaks at 2-0 where we chose the wrong pass then the massive one from Leigh to make it 4-2 when he’s about 5 yards out with a relatively easy finish (for a pro) into the far corner and he’s hit it wide. If they made the right decisions every time they wouldn’t play for a club in L2 but we really should have been more clinical – the subs wouldn’t have mattered then.
There is an attitude of “we can relax”, and it happened after the 3rd goal. Well, we cannot relax or afford to sit back-
Well, I was seething yesterday, but the morning after I find I’m feeling more positive. Because of their recent good results and the spectre of Sharp returning, Donny feels like an impossible task, but when the pressure’s on them at home, and a win seals it for them, who knows if they can handle it? it feels like Patto, Sarcevic and Bobby are returning to peak form and fitness and I’d back them to carve out chances. Just need one massive display of defensive resilience to make up for the last few weeks. How about we beat Donny and Port Vale draw with Wimbledon to leave three teams level on 78 at the top for the last game. It could yet be glorious!
These last 3 games have shown Alexander to be a brilliant man manager but tactically he’s got it wrong more times than right.
Looking ahead to Doncaster I really hope Alexander drops Neill Bryne. There’s no connection between him and Halliday and we look so vulnerable down the right hand side.
At this stage of the season it’s about playing the best available XI and Bryne is no where near it at the moment for me. It’s clear to see why he’s only ever played 3 games above League 2 and spent the vast majority of his career in non league.
A great report, thank you Adam.
The fact that on Friday, & again yesterday, there were more winning teams in the bottom 7 than the top 7 means the City players are certainly not alone in feeling the heat. This is probably the best opportunity to get out of the 4th Division we’ve had for many years, & the pressure is only increasing with every twist & turn, it would effect anyone I guess.
However, with just 2 games left to play, automatic promotion is still very much in our own hands, & I would have definitely taken that situation back in August. Wether we win draw or lose at Doncaster, it will more than likely all go down to our last game now, whatever happens.
All I hope for, is that we can go into that game against Fleetwood with matters still in our own hands. If it is, I’m sure we can finally win promotion.
Keep calm, & up the Bantams!!!
I think we need to cut the manager a bit of slack here. There have been statements on social media that he was fabricating Khela’s illness because “he didn’t look ill to me” just before he was substituted. I doubt he asks all the players at half time whether they feel ill or not so Khela must have broached it with the manager. When interviewed Alexander said there was no way he would have made the substitution at that stage unless it was necessary.
We must remember also that the analysis guy sits next to Alexander and is continually feeding the players’ stats so Khela’s may have dropped and hence why the substitution was made at that stage.
As for the whole substitutions debate we all believe we know who should replace who and when but Alexander works with all these players day in and day out and surely he must be fully aware of their abilities to come on in certain positions and do a job for the team? To now criticize him for recent substitutions is rather unfair when you look at the season as a whole when his decisions have seen the team 3rd in the division with only 2 games remaining.
Let’s be honest if we’d have been offered last August a guaranteed play off position with 2 matches left and a guaranteed automatic promotion if both matches were won with the distinct possibility that by winning both they could also be champions wouldn’t we have taken it?
Whatever happens in those games maybe we can also say what a miss Smallwood has been. The old saying “you don’t realise how good something is until you don’t have it” seems very apt to me.
Next week – the most important thing that can happen is walsall losing again
and im being 100pc serious.
I have so little faith in city getting an away win at the moment