
| Bradford City 2 |
| Powell 55, Humphrys 78 |
| Doncaster Rovers 2 |
| Thomas 74, Grehan 90+5 |
By Jason McKeown
Trying to solve one problem can sometimes create another. There is no doubt Bradford City have to become a more potent attacking side, but changing the balance of a team rarely happens cleanly. And here against Doncaster, greater prolificity was accompanied by greater leakiness.
City scored their first league goals in over a month, but they also conceded twice. Add those to the three shipped against Huddersfield last time out in the league and, across their last two games, City have doubled their goals-against tally for the entire season.
They also seemed to have misplaced a quality that has served them so well over the last couple of seasons – the ability to control a game. Here it cost them two points, when Doncaster centre back Sean Grehan was left unmarked to head home a corner. In the 95th minute. It is so un-Bradford City of recent times. And it hints at the challenge of evolving from a cautious-but-effective side into one that takes risks in pursuit of greater rewards.
The loss of game management was telling here. The flow of the match was odd, and City struggled to maintain any momentum or intensity beyond short bursts of excellence. Twice those bursts were enough to put them in a winning position – thanks to well-taken goals from Nick Powell and Stephen Humphrys. But the gaps left by their attempts to get more bodies forward were ultimately exploited. They absolutely should have won this game, yet somehow didn’t. And though referee Darren Drysdale can characteristically share some of the blame, there was no disguising the damage City caused themselves.
We’ll come back to Drysdale, but first let’s talk about a match that for so long was mind-numbingly monotonous, then exploded into action-packed drama. For 55 minutes you’d have found more entertainment watching paint dry; then suddenly you couldn’t take your eyes off what was unfolding.
Fair to say it wasn’t the type of game Michael Duff was expecting. Doncaster had lost 6-1 to MK Dons in their last game before an embarrassing 3-0 humbling to non-league Kidderminster in the FA Cup. So Grant McCann ditched his usual 4-2-3-1 and lined Doncaster up in a 5-4-1. The team bus was parked outside Valley Parade and his players parked their own bus in front of their keeper Tommy Simkin’s goal.
They’re in a tough spot. The manager is on the brink. Back to basics was the order of the day. There are more sophisticated responses to a crisis, but few quite as reassuring as adding another centre back and making the pitch feel half its normal size.
Which gave Duff a familiar headache. Teams keep setting up defensively against a goal-shy Bradford City, and the Bantams keep struggling to muster as much as a goal. The game had a tediously similar pattern to the Leyton Orient match that kicked off the Duff era – the first of five league matches out of six that City have failed to score in since he took charge.
It’s why he had no option but to tweak the balance: to find ways to be more attack-minded without losing the defensive invincibility that had seen City muster an amazing 15 clean sheets in 21 games prior to today. The difficulty is that attacking and defending are not separate functions that can be adjusted independently. Push another player forward and somebody has to cover the space he leaves. Every attempt to make City more dangerous inevitably changes the conditions in which they have to defend.
The recent goal-laced spankings of Marine and York have included hints of a tweaked attacking approach. But here, in the first proper test of the evolution, Doncaster countered with wearisome conservative blockades.
And for much of the afternoon, it left City looking just as toothless as before. Powell led the line – amazingly this counted as his full league debut, some 15 months after joining the Bantams, by which point governments had fallen, three transfer windows had opened and several Bradford roadworks had actually been completed.
Antoni Sarcevic was pushed back into the wide right forward position from which he scooped last year’s player of the season award. Kieran Morgan took Sarcevic’s attacking midfield slot after showing real promise in the cup games, whilst the return of a fit-again Josh Neufville – last seen at Luton two months ago, when Graham Alexander was still in charge – offered City greater ball-carrying thrust. Kayden Jackson took the wide left spot.
It started out promisingly and Powell headed one juicy Neufville cross just wide. But it fizzled out into tedium. Doncaster were defensively disciplined. They allowed Neufville and Ibou Touray space, prioritising congesting the central areas so that crosses into the box could be dealt with. On the rare occasions Rovers attacked, they did so in small numbers and rarely looked liable to be caught on the counter attack.
Nothing happened. Minutes ticked by without incident. The sun slowly retreated. A chilly November darkness grew. It was the sort of afternoon where the floodlights seemed to become necessary long before the football did. Valley Parade was quiet on all four sides. Neither set of supporters were being offered anything to get animated about.

But even in the stalest of stalemates, a good chance will crop up eventually. And sure enough, good work from Matt Pennington and Neufville gave Callum Connolly space to cross from a different angle, and for a split-second Doncaster switched off. Powell peeled away from his marker and nodded the ball into the back of the net. Incredibly simple. City up and running. And given Doncaster’s unwavering focus on cancelling out their opponents, it was difficult to envisage the comeback that followed.
Before we get to those moments, City could and probably should have grabbed a second to make it safe. And that’s where Drysdale comes in. Morgan went to attack a ball in the box only for George Broadbent to strike him in a desperate attempt to stop the QPR loanee. It looked worthy of a red card. And it should have been a penalty. Drysdale did nothing and turned away as Doncaster cleared. An incensed Morgan struck Broadbent in retaliation and other players joined in a shoving match. Like Drysdale, the assistant referee clearly missed it all too. Morgan was lucky not to walk, but of course Broadbent should have been punished in the first place.
Not long after, Simkin produced a wonder save to keep out Humphrys’ header, though maybe the City sub should have scored. Pennington might also be slightly rueful that he could only find the post with a header after he got free from a corner.
It was around that time McCann decided to abandon the holding plan. On came Alfie May, James Collins and Leon Ayinde. And the pattern began to change. Jordan Thomas burst into the box but shot wide when he should have hit the target, then shortly afterwards hit the bar with a volley. But the winger wasn’t to be denied, equalising with a magnificent overhead kick from Collins’ cross. The second league game in a row that City have conceded an overhead kick.
The sharp shift in momentum seemed to stump the Bantams. From posing no threat, Doncaster were suddenly full of attacking purpose and City just didn’t react. Neufville had been taken off as he eases back, resulting in Jackson moving to right wing back. In similar situations when protecting a lead this season, Sarcevic has used his experience to drop deeper alongside Connolly. Morgan lacked that nous to do the same, and City struggled to deny Doncaster the room in the middle of the park from which to mount attacks.
This was the other side of the bargain. City had committed more bodies forward and carried more threat, but when the game became stretched they no longer looked quite so comfortable controlling where it was played.
Still, Adam Phillips came on for Morgan, and a minute later City were back in front. Will Swan – who had replaced Neufville and taken Jackson’s wide left forward position – did magnificently to drive forward with the ball before setting up Humphrys for a lovely low finish.
That should really have been that. A one-goal advantage is never safe, but this City team have habitually seen situations out like this, with street-wise intelligence. Doncaster’s frail confidence fell away. Between minute 78 (when Humphrys scored) and the start of stoppage time, the visitors failed to muster a single shot on goal, had just 37.8% possession and completed just 15 accurate passes.
Yet they would go on to equalise.
Seven minutes injury time were signalled, which seemed ridiculous. But there were little signs everywhere that City weren’t handling the situation with their usual calm authority. Like keeping the ball by the corner flag way too early. Giving the ball away too easily. Dropping deeper and deeper.
Doncaster got a long throw, and City almost allowed them to equalise. Then a corner. Then another corner. Then a goal. Geehan heading home Robbie Gotts’ delivery. No one was close enough to him. City just stood there and watched him do it.

There were full-time boos and groans of frustration. They move back into the play-offs but have now won only one of their seven league games since Alexander quit the club.
All of which adds further small doubts about Duff. He hasn’t had a terrible start by any means, but his reign is still waiting for the performance that makes it feel properly up and running. City’s form is ponderous rather than purring. And here, against a side that began the day in the relegation zone, they wasted a big opportunity.
Football teams are often at their most difficult to change when there is plenty that does not need changing. Duff did not inherit a broken side. He inherited a successful one with a very obvious limitation.
That’s why it would be wrong to frame all of this as a problem Duff has created. City made an excellent start to the season under Alexander, but the margins were incredibly tight. Four of their five wins were 1-0, and when he left the Bantams were already showing signs of a goalscoring problem.
A levelling-off period was probably coming regardless of who was in charge. And even if Alexander had chosen to stay, he’d have found himself confronting the same issues that flared up after Duff arrived. It’s very unlikely they could keep edging their way to 1-0 wins all season. They had to find a way to become more attack-minded.
This table says a lot about the long-standing predicament. It’s now 51 games since Bradford City last scored three or more goals in a game, jointly with Charlton. The next longest wait among the 92? Wimbledon, on 26.
The point is, City haven’t scored more than two goals in a league match for over a year. Their struggles to score enough goals are not a new issue caused by Duff, and they needed to be addressed whoever is in the dugout.
Part of the reason City have been so meagre in front of goal is that they’re set up to give the defence a huge level of protection. Their outstanding defensive record is largely a validation of this approach – and it earned them a play-off finish last season. This time around they’ve become even more defensively cautious, and with it more impotent in attack.
So Duff is trying to fix that balance. It’s a small dial change but a difficult one to get right, and the last two league games have underlined it. City needed to loosen the handbrake. They had to become more adventurous. They had to find more goals. But if they lose the control and defensive resilience that got them this far, the cure risks becoming more damaging than the original problem.
Getting that balance right could define Bradford City’s season – and very possibly Michael Duff’s time in charge.
Categories: Match Reviews
Six of the best as Bradford City’s kids turn a meaningless night into one to remember
Bradford City find some healing in a magnificent seven
Three minutes of madness
The extraordinary is starting to feel normal for Bradford City
A frustrating afternoon.
We’re struggling to defend long throws and set pieces. This pre-dates Duff.
We also seem reluctant when attacking to try to take on defenders. We don’t dribble. So when we can’t pass through a dense defensive line (like today, and like in many league games this season) we look unthreatening.
We seem most potent when moving at speed. Nuefville’s return today was encouraging here. And our 2nd goal was a direct result of the McCracken acting quickly and catalysing a fast-paced attack.
A shout-out for the Doncaster keeper’s save from Humphreys’ header. Of all the live games I’ve seen, this moment was perhaps one of the most surprised I’ve been that the ball didn’t end up rippling the net.
We still have potential. I don’t think we should be too downbeat.
I have to defend the Ref. Drysdale here. He was following play when the Morgan incident happened. He had his back to it as play carried on as Doncaster tried to break. That why he asked the linesman who indicated, a coming together. Morgan punched the Doncaster player on the head, so if the ref had seen it he would have been sent off.
It was “handbags” before the Morgan punch.
I’m not blaming him for the Morgan incident and he is very lucky no one saw what he did. But Drysdale should have acted on Broadbent striking out in my opinion.
Broadbent 100% punches Morgan in the head first.
A tough watch first half but a great second half of entertainement, spoilt only by conceeding on 95 minutes. If you score an equiliser at that stage of the game it feels like a win and conceeding can feel a bit like a loss (2 points anyway!).
I thought the Ref had a pretty good game (for a change at City) and let the play continue as much as he could rather blowing up every two minutes. He tried to let the game flow, which was a task on its own for the first 55 minues.
Overall a draw doesn’t really cut it but has put us back in the playoffs. Hopefully a good win against Barnsley will keep us in there.
It’s still early days with Duff but I really believe he will find that missing bit sooner rather than later to get the team clicking properly up front whilst maintaining a certain degree of safety at the back. Here’s hoping!!
The defence couldn’t cope with Donnys changes when they went more attacking and that’s a worry. We also appeared caught between whether to try to see the game out or go for a third.
Mind you there’s no excuse for a defender not doing his job properly from a corner in the 95th minute.
Thanks WOAP – Hamstrung by a huge lack of midfield options so we have no option to play a low black midfield when needed. I can only assume January will bring some much needed reinforcements if we lose Connelly we literally have one specialist midfielder. The others are all naturally attacking midfielders which we seem to have an abundance of. It will give Duff more options and doesn’t necessarily mean a negative line up but certainly easier to shut up shop and get control back. Too many basketball type games (albeit great to watch!) Great to have Josh back today