Stuart McCall underlines his greater experience and ability as City move closer to top six finish

Image by Thomas Gadd

Match review: Bradford City 1 (Law) Oxford United 0

By Tim Penfold

We knew from the beginning that Stuart McCall’s teams would play prettier football than Phil Parkinson’s.  That was the Parkinson style, especially last season – results over aesthetics, and it turned us from a team on the verge of dropping out of the league to a team on the verge of the Championship.  But the big question was “can McCall’s teams grind out the results needed?”

In his first spell as manager this was their weakness.  McCall’s teams could destroy opponents, but when the pressure was on they fell apart.  Eight years and a spell at Motherwell later, and how things have changed.  Oxford played well today – their pressing game shut us down well in the first half and they caused us problems at the back – but City scrapped for everything and saw the game out.  This team is tougher than the 2008/09 squad, and it shows.

The first half was low on quality chances.  Both teams tried to play short passing games, but both were neutralised by the pressure and defence of their opponents.  City, reverting to a 4-4-2, were unable to get their main creators into the game – Nicky Law forced too deep and Mark Marshall double marked – and what scraps fell to Jordy Hiwula and Charlie Wyke were well mopped up by the Oxford defence, and going forward the pacy Marvin Johnson and the tricky Chris Maguire threatened.  Oxford’s best chance was put wide by centre back Curtis Nelson, while City had a Hiwula shot blocked and a McArdle header pushed wide.

City, as they have made a habit of doing recently, came out stronger in the second half.  Wyke’s header from a corner was cleared off the line, and they were able to pressure the Oxford defence more, with a couple of openings denied by some bizarre refereeing.  But still the breakthrough did not come, and Oxford looked dangerous.

Then came a moment that shows how different a manager McCall is from the first time around.  During a break in play, Hiwula and Law were called over to the touchline for new tactical instructions.  City now played a 4-2-1-3, with Hiwula on the left and Law in the hole, and it soon produced an opening.  Hiwula found space with good control and a quick one-two, and spread the ball over to Marshall on the right.  Finally free of his markers, Marshall swung a cross in towards Wyke and his header down fell into the path of Law a yard out, who made no mistake.

Oxford immediately responded, and Conor McAleny forced a couple of good saves from Colin Doyle, but City looked good defensively with Tony McMahon making one spectacular saving tackle in the penalty box.  City also looked dangerous on the counter, with Josh Cullen firing over and Charlie Wyke, for once able to get away from the constant presence of Oxford defenders hanging on to his shirt, spun and volleyed from wide of the box, forcing a good save from Simon Eastwood in the Oxford goal.

Oxford brought on more forwards as the game went on and went more direct, but Rory McArdle and Nathaniel Knight-Percival headed everything clear.

This, then, was a victory of heart as much as it was of skill.  City’s players left everything out on the field.  Charlie Wyke, who was given no help from the referee despite the Oxford defence’s attempts to swap shirts during the game, was superb, winning headers, holding the ball up and causing so many problems.  Late on in the game he finally got a free kick for an offence that had gone unpunished numerous times before, and it was greeted with a standing ovation.  Most of that was aimed sarcastically at the referee, but City’s number nine deserved just as much for a brilliant display.

And it was a victory for Stuart McCall.  His substitutions, like at Bury last week, were spot on, with Timothee Dieng and Stephen Darby coming on to kill the game off, and his in-game tactical switch was key to our win.  He’s a much better manager now than he was the first time around, and deserves both the plaudits and the play off spot.

Categories: Match Reviews

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

9 replies

  1. Brilliant season so far..just about there..but really need a win over the Blades to secure fourth. A cup final on Easter Monday awaits!

  2. Since the scunthorpe defeat mcalls game management has been spot on on. He’s learnt alot and nothing like the team and manager he was last time around at city 2009. City will make the playoffs and win at wembley.

  3. Always wondered why players like Wyke (or all players, in fact) don’t just put on the tightest shirt covered in gel or bryll cream. You can still have your arm or shorts pulled but would be much more obvious and likely to get you a free-kick.

    Most referees ignore shirt-pulling and I think its just seen as part of the game.

    • this referee also didn’t see bear hugging as an issue either. The Wyke volley came out of pure anger as 2 seconds earlier he was being grabbed round the waist in clear sight of the referee.

  4. For the first three quarters of the season, the perception was that we played attractive, skillfull football, but earned apparently more draws than any club in Europe…for the last 2 months, the perception has been the team haven’t played their best football…but over the last 10 games, our points form are the second highest in the league.

    Is this a more pragmatic style of play? Players subconciously showing a more ruthless finishing, as we finally reach the sharp end of the season? Or just a change in luck, with more of those millions of missed chances from earlier on, finally hitting the back of the net?

  5. Other correspondents, particularly Tim, have summed up the game very well. I thought Oxford were a good side, very quick at intercepting and closing City down. But for dreadful finishing they should maybe have got a draw. But City did well, particularly in seeing out the excessive 5 minute extra time so easily.
    But , to me, the real feature of the game was the appalling refereeing. Wyke was pulled, pushed, grabbed, elbowed, and received no protection. The lowlight, though , was a goal-kick give to Oxford in the second half. I was dead in line withe th dead-ball line, and Hiwula stopped the ball on the line. A goal kick was given by a linesman about 75 yards away. A dangerous move ruined. That summed up the officials, whose performance should, even though it won’t, be studied by the League.

  6. I thought Oxford were very good – clearly well drilled by Appleton. Very important three points for City given Bolton’s stumble today. Hopefully The Blades will be still hungover on Monday, or letting fringe players have a go? If we moved to within a point of Bolton on Monday they may start falling apart (of they aren’t already), then who knows…….

  7. Stuart has also got a much better assistant manager than he had last time, makes a huge difference.

%d bloggers like this: