Life goes on: Bradford City answer uncertainty with resilient display

Reading 1
Godwin-Malife 66
Bradford City 1
Beesley 4

By Jason McKeown

In a week when uncertainty has surrounded Bradford City, certainty emerged from a welcome source: the character of the players. All the noise and questions surrounding Graham Alexander’s departure and what comes next could easily have seeped into an anxious Bantams display. Add in the absence of several key players, and the ingredients were there for a difficult afternoon.

Instead, City produced a performance that offered reassurance. Their winning run may have ended with a second-half Reading equaliser, but there was enough resilience, poise and quality on display to suggest the foundations built over the past three years are not suddenly about to crumble. Life after Alexander has begun. And, at least on this evidence, life goes on.

For much of the afternoon, events lived up to the French philosophy “The more things change, the more they stay the same”. That phrase came from the writer Jean-Baptiste Alphonse Karr, who observed that despite superficial shifts or new technologies, underlying human nature and societal patterns often remain identical.

In the Bantams’ case, it really was identical. Two weeks on from taking the lead at Luton through a fourth-minute goal involving a header and Bobby Pointon, City began their next league game with a fourth-minute goal involving a header and Bobby Pointon.

Just as at Kenilworth Road, City’s early breakthrough here paved the way for a game of not much happening, with the Bantams holding their hosts at arm’s length while allowing them to run out of ideas. And after everything we’ve experienced between the trip to Luton and the visit to Reading, it was both reassuring and strange to see City perform exactly as they had.

Sadly of course, it could not stay exactly the same forever.

Reading came out fired up for the second half and deserved their equaliser when it came. It was the first goal City have conceded in some 336 minutes of league action. And it led to what has become an unusually rare outcome for this Bradford City side: a draw. In fact, this was only the seventh draw they’ve been involved in across their last 49 league and cup games.

Perhaps Udoka Godwin-Malife’s goal for Reading was a hint that different, less enjoyable times might lie ahead for City. But the way the team responded to being pegged back offered reassurance that they remain capable of handling whatever comes next.

Heads did not drop after Reading’s equaliser. Instead, City climbed the gears and dominated large spells in the push for a late winning goal. That one didn’t materialise was disappointing, but the attacking prowess shown was heartening. The team and Mark Trueman deserve to feel good about their efforts here.

There was a lot to like over the 90 minutes, not least that early goal. This time Pointon was the provider rather than the scorer, but the role of others was equally important. Kayden Jackson – who filled in at right wing-back with Josh Neufville injured – played the ball to Aden Baldwin, who delivered a sublime low cross-field pass to Ibou Touray, who wonderfully laid the ball into the path of Pointon, who delivered a stunning cross. And who is that towering figure who got on the end of Pointon’s ball to powerfully head it into the top corner? Jake Beesley – off the mark at last!

What a superb header. What a superb goal.

Beesley led the line expertly. Finally getting off the mark left him looking like a player with the weight lifted from his shoulders, and he was unfortunate not to get a second when he went slightly too early to run onto an Adam Phillips pass, found the back of the net, but was correctly flagged offside.

No matter, City were managing those small margins well. Reading showed plenty of promise with Kyreece Lisbie a handful on the left, but the Bantams backline was in usual solid form and back-up keeper Cameron Dawson had little to do beyond palming out a long-range Lewis Wing effort. Baldwin was the pick of the centre backs, even though he was slightly fortunate to stay on the field for a high tackle that drew a yellow card when other referees would have issued a red.

Reading definitely upped it after the break, with former City centre back Paudie O’Connor heading just over from a corner. But without their injured top scorer Jack Marriott, they lacked an attacking punch. So it became a match of lots of Reading possession but few efforts at either end. For City’s part, they went from the 23rd minute to the 65th without registering a shot.

But a minute after City finally mustered a second-half attempt, Reading went up the other end and scored. Randell Williams sent a long throw into the box that was laid off by Jacob Brown, allowing right back Godwin-Malife to run on and hit a low shot that deflected into the goal.

That was when City retook control, aided by the introduction of George Lapslie and Nick Powell. Between the restart and Reading’s equaliser, the home side had 70% possession. But over the final 24 minutes plus stoppage time, the pendulum swung to City having 62% of the ball.

And they might have made that count. Jackson twice got into positions to produce cross-shot efforts, and twice Joel Pereira kept him out. Touray later sent a low cross into the box from which Powell produced a clever flick that rolled just wide of the post. Swan joined the action for Pointon – who, like Baldwin, produced a tackle that felt orange card territory. Lapslie caused problems. But City could not make their territorial advantage count.

Still, this was a good performance. Touray deserves a huge amount of credit for racing back from international duty to play here. Jackson did an admirable job as right wing-back. Phillips and Beesley had their best games in weeks. Callum Connolly and Antoni Sarcevic battled well in midfield. George Pratt had some uncomfortable moments but got through them. Matt Pennington keeps doing Matt Pennington things.

But despite all the positives and fact the game was played in bright October sunshine, those clouds of ambiguity could not be shifted over the team’s heads. Just before kick off, strong reports emerged that Michael Duff will be the next Bradford City manager. It seems the Bantams have made their choice, and an official announcement will follow in the coming days.

It is fair to say it is not an inspiring choice, although worth asking: who would be? At WOAP we’ll have plenty to say if and when Duff is confirmed. But for now, at least, it’s worth noting that Duff’s managerial style and preferred way of playing have very similar hallmarks to Alexander’s. Based on all the names linked to the post over the past few days, Duff is probably the closest fit to the continuity candidate that many of us believe the club should be looking for.

Whatever transpires, the noise neatly bookends a week where no supporter has been fully thinking about this game at Reading, and probably will have bigger distractions than chewing the fat over this performance.

Yet while City ceded top spot and saw their winning run end, this afternoon offered a timely reminder that the story of this season was never solely about the man in the dugout. Alexander leaves behind a team with clear identity, strong habits and an impressive collective spirit. Those qualities were evident throughout this performance.

The uncertainty remains, but so too does plenty of reason for optimism.



Categories: Match Reviews

Tags: , , ,

31 replies

  1. This was a good point all things considered. On another day we might have held on for all three but we were a bit disjointed and sluggish up to their goal and then came on stronger. As Jason says, Michael Duff is not the most inspiring choices if he is the one. It’s hard to believe we can’t get somebody with a better recent track record who is based in the north of England. But if he’s the one, he’s got to be given the chance to get on with it and make his mark.

    • I seriously cannot think of better than Duff, to carry on GA’s great work.

      In the same way that I was pleased that the Cowley’s turned us down, I’m equally pleased that Challinor is apparently not interested. That Stockport team of last season should have done far better, than limp to a thrashing against Bolton at Wembley.

  2. If it’s Duff, then that’s a great choice and I’m a bit puzzled why so many are against it.

    Not as many as were against GA though – reading the comments that greeted his appointment are good entertaining read.

    Duff is a good choice because he’s had success in terms of promotions or play-off finals at L1/L2 level. (I’d love to know what a better alternative is – I can’t think of one)

    Crucially, he got the best out of Adam Phillips (I think it was 15 goals / assists) who under his tenure got Barnsley player of the year and was in most pundits best team for that season.

    Those wanting to focus on his Huddersfield and Wycombe stints, need to remember that those clubs are simply not very well run. As illustrated by Duff, who had been asking for a striker all summer, singing Wareham and not even been given the chance to see him play.

    We are a well run club. And so for the first time since his time at Barnsley, he joins a club who will give him unstinted support. In fact, we’re in a better position than Barnsley was when he took over.

    Finally note, that Cheltenham, Barnsley and Huddersfield all went backwards after he left.

    • Many of our ‘on line” supporters tbink we are in the championship if not above. They think the like of Steve Cooper, Rob Edwards etc are going to come to us. Deluded. We most of all want someone who will recognise how good this team is and resist wholesale change in favour of tweaks here and there. Who that is? There are people at City more knowledgeable than me. Duff? Rowett? Lee Johnson? Richardson? No idea but I will shout my heart out for whoever it is if we maintain the form.

  3. I was proud of City today

    A fairly even game but I thought we probably just won “on points “.

    We played well, tough and hard. Powell was brilliant

    Re the new manager, I trust the management to get it right

    Very happy

  4. if Duff is to be our new manager because “he impressed and spoke really well at interview” then I have to ask, just what being a good talker has to do with being a good football manager. There is scant success in his CV and even that was achieved when Boris Johnson was still struggling to get brexit done. Since then, a short list of failures from a guy who refuses to move house from Cheltenham. Having supported City for 60+ years I’m struggling to remember such an underwhelming appointment. Top of Division one and battling for promotion? Is this really the best we can do?

    • It’s as much an underwhelming appointment as Graham Alexander was! Or would an overwhelming Mark Hughes type appointment be better?

      I don’t know the answer, neither does anyone else. Only time will tell.

      I do know that my Town supporting mates thought Duff should have been given more time there and were disappointed he got the sack when he did. Town were in (and still are) a ‘sack the manager every time the fans turn’ phase so I wouldn’t read too much into that. He looks as good a choice as anyone to me.

    • What? Been the only manager to get Barnsley to the play-offs in years, is “scant success”?

      Goodness knows what you said when GA got appointed!!

      Give us your choice and in what way they would be better than Duff.

    • Yeah, in fairness his Barnsley team which got to the play off final had the 5th biggest budget and they finished 4th on 86 points, so around where they should have finished. But, they did only lose 1-0 to Wednesday who’s budget was about £4.4m higher than Barnsley’s and they beat Wednesday twice that season, home and away.

      His exploits with Cheltenham were very impressive though given they finished 1st in league 2 with the 17th biggest budget and then they finished comfortably in 15th in league 1 with the 21st biggest budget.

      As with many managerial appointments each side could probably make a compelling argument for why it will or won’t work but only time will truly tell. He was unfairly dismissed at Huddersfield after they’d only won 4 times in 15 matches but had massive injuries and were still 6th. For comparison, of our last 15 matches of last season, including the play offs, Alexander only won 5 times.

  5. During that first half we played as well as I’ve seen in the season thus far. An excellent move for the goal, firmly despatched by Beesley. While Alexander has taken most of the credit, I think Lucketti has probably played a major part in organising our defence. We were so well drilled again today. Dawson looked competent and their goal was deflected past him, by Pratt, I think. Phillips hasn’t yet found his feet and is capable of providing far more. I was delighted when we signed him because of his form at Barnsley but, as yet, he’s making little impact.

    Nick Powell is a class apart and I hope we can eke more minutes out of him.

    All in all, given the disrupted week, it was a well earned point.

    Like many fans, I’m not enthused by the the names being tipped for the vacancy but have to admit the appointment of Alexander didn’t fill me with enthusiasm either – and his reign didn’t turn out too bad. If Duff is the chosen one, it must be stipulated his full time presence is a prerequesite and he can’t subcontract his duties to his assistant, so he can spend part of the week at home in Cheltenham.

    • Have you any proof that Duff spent less time with his players than GA did?

      Or are you and others making a big thing about managers needing to live locally, even though GA never did?

      • Geographic location is important to some. Clear examples of this can seen from this summer. We lost our Captain to Wigan due to location, we lost our first choice Centre-half to Burton due to location, we lost our first choice goalkeeper to Watford due to location. And one reason amongst several other factors we lost GA to PNE was due to location.

        Former chairman Geoffrey Richmond believed a manager needed to be fully integrated into the local community to match his own relentless, “first in, last out” work ethic. Which was partly the reason he dismissed Stapleton and Pearson.

        Of course Managers can successfully commute, however to have one living local is more beneficial.

      • I don’t disagree. But an awful lot is been made of this, given that there is little evidence that it makes a difference.

        Presumably, because it’s linked to him not wanting to uproot his family, he must have ‘commuted’ when he was at Barnsley.

    • I agree that we played well in the first quarter but was a little disappointed that we started to ‘manage the game’ so early in the match after the goal went in..

      Strolling to take the corners and throw ins promoted a negative mindset, the intensity drops and initiative is handed over to the opposition. We allowed Reading back into the game. If you do concede then its all the more difficult to up your intensity again.

      Fair play to the team though. They did finish strongly and a point away from home after a difficult week is admiral.

      Also shout out to the supporters who were down there in numbers. Given the circumstances it would have been understandable if some of them chose not to make the long journey down.

      I’ve long since given up who would be a good appointment for City. On paper Hughes, Bowyer, Robson, Taylor were ‘marquee’ signings and did nothing whilst, Dolan, Kamara, Jewel, Alexander were underwhelming ones who went onto do great things. Perhaps success on the field is depends on more than just who is sat in the dug out…

    • When he was Barnsley manager it appears he would stay locally through the week and drive home after matchdays

      Not ideal but workable

      • I have to agree with you here. Apparently he has teenage kids at secondary. Being a parent myself, it’s far more stressful uprooting kids during their final school years. For me, leaving them settled at home would leave me free to concentrate on work.

  6. Would we have won today if Alexander was in charge? I reckon we would, we let Reading come on strong after half time up until their goal. I think a GA half time talk may have got us more front footed and proactive. I still can’t believe he’s jumped ship (for all I understand his decision to go, that’s how it is for me). When Powell came on it changed the games momentum, he galvanised the team and I thought we looked more likely to win it. He’s a seriously impressive player.

    All things taken into account it’s a solid point on the road and our goal was fantastic from start to finish. I’m happy with that performance.

    Upwards and onwards 💪

  7. good point away from home. Probably would have been better making some of the substitutions before they scored but who knows. Well done everyone 🐓.

  8. Hiring a manager to harness the existing players talents and team shape makes a lot of sense. The fact he won’t be local and have to travel significantly is a concern.

    For all those underwhelmed at Duff I point to Kamara Jewell and Parkinson. Moaners everywhere for those appointments. Lacking ambition, cheap option, outdated long ball football.

    All three were successful in context of bigger name managers who were employed by the club, Lennie Lawrence, Peter Taylor, Mark Hughes for example.

    We all know there are no guarantees in football but the board has earned my trust at appointing the right man for the job and only time will tell.

    Hiring a heavy possession based manager now would feel the wrong move with this group. God forbid a move back to a defence passing the ball sideways with no intent as under Hughes.

    Hopefully whoever comes in and if it is Duff, continues the good work and ethics embedded during Alexander’s reign.

    • Yes!! Several have pointed out on other forums, that our most succesful managers, i.e. Jewell, Parkinson and GA have all been castigated as rubbish appointments.

      Frankly, we know nothing. And I’m always amazed how much attention is given to fans choices when picking the manager.

  9. A massive well done to Mark & all the players for the way they went about a very tricky Away day, under very trying recent circumstances. My fears of a disjointed, out of sorts performance didn’t materialize, & the shear work ethic looked as strong as always. A slight criticism, I just thought if Mark had sent Powell on while we were ahead, that might have maintained enough momentum to have either seen the game out, or perhaps increase our lead. But to be honest, due to all the emotions felt by everyone this week, I thought we did superbly well.

    This were I line myself up to be shot down (be gentle)

    There are a couple of people who haven’t had as much attention for the job, who I personally think might be good appointments.

    Nigel Clough, could be a good choice (A 100% players manager – loyal – transparent & tactically minded) the Mansfield players would run through walls for him.

    Neil Harris, successful manager – makes football simple & clear, all his teams are very hard to beat.

    I think either manager would have the commitment, and football acumen to help take us into a higher division given time. But quite honestly, whoever takes the job, it wont be easy following on from our previous manager, & I would wish them the very best.

    Up the Bantams!

  10. Te those saying we ought to have made changes before the Reading goal, Powell and Lapslie were there waiting for next time the ball went out, when Reading scored

    • their goal had been coming for a while.

      • Thanks – literally my point – changes were already prepared before they scored – not in response to conceding.
        Whether they were the right changes is another debate – though Powell was excellent once again and unlucky not to score.

      • my point is it was too late by then……

  11. Our online supporters seem to be an odd bunch. Why all the moans and negativity about the likes of Duff, Rowett, Heckingbottom etc? We are nenver gping to attract Rob Edwards etc. We are a good team, in a good place. This rarely happens in manager changes. We need to carry on and tweak only minor areas for the season. Someone who knows this is the one for us. Duff has been at some unsettled clubs recently whereas we are not. If is him (and I’m still not convinced) then lets give him the full support. I still think it will be a surprise appointment (and not Truman).

  12. Sky are reporting Duffer will be revealed tomorrow as City manager

  13. A decent point at somewhere we got nothing from last season and given how difficult our opening 5 away games looked 10 points is a very respectable return.

    Obviously a lot of fortune that Marriott was out injured and maybe Reading will regret not postponing their past 2 games, given they drew them both; certainly don’t blame them, they saw an opportunity to play teams who’d been weakened more than they had but it hasn’t really worked out for them with only 2 points and an injury to their star man.

    Duff will be our new Gaffer and let’s get behind him and hope we see the maintenance of our current form / place in the top 6. However, we should also have perspective, I’m sure plenty of aCity fans felt we’d finish somewhere between 6th-10th this season, so our positive start shouldn’t give us a false sense that we have a right to be in the top 2-3 teams.

    I’m not talking our chances down either, just focusing on what’s realistic.