Continuity coup or a Duff appointment? Assessing Bradford City’s new manager

By Jason McKeown

Bradford City are about to name Michael Duff as their new manager, with the 48-year-old expected to be in the Valley Parade hotseat before the weekend visit of Leyton Orient.

Duff arrives less than a month after been sacked by Wycombe Wanderers following a poor start to the season. It means City have replaced a manager they lost upwards with one who recently departed another League One club downwards. Looked at purely through that lens, it’s not difficult to understand why the appointment feels underwhelming.

But there is considerably more to Duff’s record than his difficult final weeks at Wycombe. And perhaps more importantly, there is plenty about the way he manages that suggests City have found a way to deliver continuity rather than risk changing course.

A potted history of Michael Duff

Like Graham Alexander, Michael Duff is something of a Burnley cult hero after spending 12 years at Turf Moor and racking up three promotions on his CV. He retired in 2016 and coached different Burnley youth teams, before getting his first manager job in 2018 at the same club where he had begun his playing career, Cheltenham Town.

At Whaddon Road, Duff guided Cheltenham to promotion when they went up from League Two as champions in the behind-closed-doors Covid season of 2020/21 (having finished in the play-offs the year before). He then led the Robins to their highest-ever league finish when they placed 15th in League One. During that summer Duff decided to leave, and ended up taking the reins at fellow League One side Barnsley.

He only had one year at Oakwell, but it was some ride. His 2022/23 Barnsley team won plenty of admirers for their adventurous style. They finished fourth, racking up an impressive 86 points and scoring 80 goals, defeated Bolton in the play-offs, before narrowly losing the Wembley final 1-0 to Sheffield Wednesday.

According to the Yorkshire Post’s Leon Wobschall, when Duff came in, “they’d been relegated and it was a real mess. They lost between £6-7m, there was a lot of tension between the fans and the owners…To get to the play-off final, within one game of an instant return, no one expected that at all. His budget wasn’t one of the highest in the division. He was competing with Ipswich, Sheffield Wednesday, their wage bills were far bigger.”

That part of Duff’s CV feels especially pertinent now. City have just lost a manager whose great strength was extracting results beyond the level of his resources. At Barnsley at least, Duff demonstrated an ability to do something similar. 

Duff was poached by Championship club Swansea during the summer of 2023. The move represented the high point of his managerial stock, at least so far.

Following in the footsteps of the expansive Russell Martin, Duff tried to implement a more pragmatic style of play. Fans derided it for not being “The Swansea way” and he was sacked after only 21 games in charge (he won only six). Swansea were 18th in the table and had won just one of their last eight games. To make matters worse, in the build-up to the big Welsh derby against Cardiff, Duff declared the game was “not the be-all-and-end-all”. This did not go down well with fans. Neither, unsurprisingly, did losing the derby.

Rob Phillips, BBC Wales football correspondent, wrote when Duff was sacked, “There is now something in the DNA at Swansea City where style matters, and Duff never appeared to be the correct fit…It is difficult not to feel sympathy with Duff. At another club, his management ethos and method might work. But in so many ways, Swansea are different.”

There’s perhaps a lesson for City in Duff’s Swansea failure. The problem wasn’t simply that Duff wanted to manage in a particular way, but that his way jarred with how Swansea saw themselves. The Bantams are in almost the opposite position. They don’t need a new manager to impose a different footballing identity; they need someone capable of preserving the successful one Alexander has left behind.

Duff was back in management the following summer (2024), this time at Huddersfield – freshly relegated from the Championship. He didn’t do badly, with a 16-game unbeaten run at one point lifting them to fourth. But a March slide of four defeats in five saw Town drop out of the play-offs and he was sacked.

“I really like Michael as a person and I know how diligently he has worked for the club since he was appointed as head coach in the summer, so we’ve all been desperate for him to succeed,” said Kevin Nagle at the time. “However, our results on the pitch since the turn of the year have simply not been good enough.”

It’s worth noting that Huddersfield were seventh when they dismissed Duff. Two points off the play-offs, with 10 games to go. They ended up finishing 10th, then ninth last season. They did not prosper after sacking Duff. And the ongoing revolving door of managerial changes in Kirklees would suggest the problems ran considerably deeper than the man in the dugout.

That offers another interesting contrast with the job Duff walks into now. Bradford City are not searching for an identity or trying to recover from failure. They know what is working. The task for Duff is much clearer: protect it, build on it and avoid disturbing the foundations Alexander has left behind.

The Town sacking ultimately paved the way for Duff to go to Wycombe, another job that ultimately ended in disappointment. He took charge in September 2025 and was able to lift a struggling Wanderers from a League One relegation fight to play-off contention, before they fell away at the final hurdle and finished 11th. Duff was sacked after a slow start to this campaign that saw them winless, including an especially poor 5-1 hammering at Stockport.

Summarising his spell at Wycombe, Bucks Free Press reporter James Richings wrote, “His tenure will be remembered as one that began with considerable promise, showed flashes of genuine progress, but ultimately failed to deliver the consistency required to move Wycombe Wanderers forward.”

Wycombe is harder to explain away and represents the most immediate reason for caution about Duff’s appointment. City are effectively betting that the manager who previously succeeded with Cheltenham and Barnsley is a better indication of what they are getting than the one who has just endured a difficult few months at Wycombe.

Five managerial jobs have produced a decidedly mixed record for Duff. Cheltenham was an undoubted success and Barnsley largely was too. Swansea clearly wasn’t. Huddersfield and Wycombe are more complicated, with enough mitigation to prevent either being straightforward evidence that Duff’s managerial stock has permanently fallen.

But equally, there is no getting away from the fact his recent CV contains three sackings.

What kind of manager is Duff?

If City’s overriding priority was to maintain what Alexander had built, it isn’t difficult to see the attraction of Duff.

Duff and Alexander shared a dressing room at Turf Moor for four seasons and appear to see the game in similar ways. That stylistic overlap is likely to have featured heavily in City’s thinking. Indeed, the club may have asked Alexander to recommend his successor and Duff put forward.

Right from his Cheltenham days, Duff has favoured three at the back. He generally uses a 3-5-2 formation with a focus on attacking from wide positions. Duff’s teams are aggressive out of possession and press hard. His Barnsley team were one of the most aggressive League One pressing teams in the last decade.

Three at the back, aggressive out of possession, pressing hard…these are the traits of Alexander’s Bradford City. Duff’s favoured approach matches it well. As our own Alex Scott said on our recent podcast, “He gets criticised by fans mostly for being too dedicated to three at the back, too dedicated to direct counter-attacking, and for high pressing stuff. The things he’s being critiqued for would work quite well here.”

Duff is at heart a pragmatist who does not worry about trying to dominate possession. You could see why this style did not find favour at a club like Swansea, but was more appreciated at Barnsley at least. As EFL expert Gab Sutton recently wrote, “Duff values stability in defence, and that’s something he can build on at Valley Parade.”

Interestingly, at Wycombe Duff did move away from three at the back, opting for a 4-2-3-1 formation. Wycombe pressed less aggressively than some of Duff’s previous teams. Even so, he’s unlikely to walk into the Bradford City 3-4-3 set-up and want to radically transform it.

In that sense, Duff looks very much like the continuity appointment City needed.

Why have City gone for Duff?

The imminent appointment for Duff brings to an end a relatively quick recruitment search by Bradford City, certainly vastly speedier than the 33 days it took the club to replace Mark Hughes with Alexander.

The club kept their counsel throughout, and all we could go on was rumours and journalist updates. It appears Paul Heckingbottom might have been the favoured candidate, but he opted to decline the opportunity to interview for the job. Given he was recently sacked by Preston and may feel he can land a more attractive role in time, that’s fair enough.

David Challinor was also linked, but reports suggest he did not want to be considered. And though some in-work managers like Tom Cleverley and Leam Richardson were mentioned – the latter even responding to media questions about the link – there didn’t appear to be anything in it.  

It seemed that there were two serious contenders. Duff, of course, and Gary Rowett. The latter is out of work having left Leicester in the summer. He has spent most of his managerial career in the Championship and has a decent pedigree, but his playing style is less compatible with Alexander’s, and the fact recent jobs haven’t gone brilliantly gives him the whiff of being slightly past his best before date.

So Duff it is.

How do we view this appointment?

Whoever Bradford City picked to replace Graham Alexander, there was a good chance it was going to feel underwhelming.

That’s not the same thing as saying Duff is a bad appointment.

It’s the difficult reality of replacing a manager who had substantially outperformed the resources available to him. That became even more apparent with the list of names linked with the vacancy in recent days. We will all have our own views on each prospect’s fit for the role, but there wasn’t anyone who fully inspired confidence they are as good or an upgrade on Alexander.

It’s the price of success. Part of what will have attracted Alexander to Preston is that he appears to have significantly overachieved at Valley Parade. A fourth-place finish in League One last season, on a budget ranked 13th or 14th highest in the division. Top of the league this season before leaving, on a similar budget. Preston, who are competing in a Championship full of clubs with budgets far higher than theirs, will value the idea that in Alexander they could get more from less.

Viewed through this metric, if there was someone available out there with a better record than Alexander, Preston would surely have been looking at them too. So City began their search for his replacement, knowing they were unlikely to find someone genuinely comparable. They were replacing a manager who had, in effect, performed well beyond the level City could reasonably expect to recruit from.

We see this sort of trend happen often in football, especially when star players leave clubs they have outgrown. Luis Suarez and Liverpool in 2014, Gareth Bale and Tottenham in 2013, Nahki Wells at City in 2014. Go further back and there’s Stuart McCall and John Hendrie in 1988.

You lose someone integral to your success because a bigger club wants them too. You bank the money, but then discover the fundamental problem: the very reason they left makes it difficult to attract someone of equivalent quality.

City received a handsome fee for Wells and handed his number 21 shirt to Aaron McLean. We know how that went.

Losing Alexander, even with the reported £500,000 City received in compensation, presents something similar. There are of course better managers out there. Whether better managers were available, attainable and wanted to manage Bradford City is another matter.

Inevitably, the realistic shortlist contained candidates whose recent achievements could not match Alexander’s. That explains some of the underwhelming feeling around this appointment, a feeling that probably would have accompanied whoever got the job.

That’s not to write off Duff and his prospects for taking City forward. Alexander himself was not an exciting appointment in 2023. Phil Parkinson didn’t set pulses racing when he arrived in 2011. Geoffrey Richmond once claimed the permanent appointment of Paul Jewell in the summer of 1998 caused the club to lose 2,000 season ticket holders. First impressions aren’t what ultimately determine whether a managerial appointment succeeds.

The encouraging thing for Duff is that he does not inherit a broken football club. Alexander leaves behind a side at the top end of League One, a well-drilled squad and a way of playing that has proved hugely effective. This should be a job requiring evolution rather than revolution.

But that brings its own pressure.

Because maintaining what Alexander achieved requires more than competent management. It requires Duff to continue outperforming City’s resources.

If a budget ranked somewhere around the middle of League One produces a team finishing somewhere around the middle of League One, Duff won’t necessarily have done a bad job. He’ll have delivered roughly what the resources suggest he should.

The problem is that Alexander changed our idea of what was normal.

And that is perhaps the greatest challenge facing Duff. He’s not merely replacing Bradford City’s manager. He’s replacing the man who made fourth place feel repeatable, and then made first place feel possible.

What about the commute?

There’s been some noise that Duff wouldn’t be a great choice because of the fact he still lives in Cheltenham. At some of his recent previous jobs, it has been a talking point amongst fans because he didn’t fully relocate.

When at Barnsley he talked about his 150-mile commute, “It’s important that I am a dad and a husband (at home). When I drive back, I spend most of my time on the phone as when I am at home, I can’t be on the phone. It is a big deal as they (family) were part of the decision to come.”

Duff’s desire to remain living in Cheltenham certainly caused some controversy among fans at Swansea. The journey between Cheltenham and Swansea was around two hours each way. When Swansea chairman Andy Coleman dismissed Duff, his statement thanked Duff and his family for the sacrifices they had made before adding, “Being present in Swansea matters.”

The unconfirmed suggestion is Duff rented a flat locally when managing Barnsley (in the town centre) and Huddersfield (in nearby Holmfirth). He would go ‘home’ to his family one or two times a week, but be present for training and games.

You would like to assume he will do something similar when managing City. Google Maps says that the drive from Cheltenham to the Woodhouse Grove training ground is a 188-mile journey that takes three-and-a-half hours. That doesn’t seem workable, which is where the worries come in.

When Peter Taylor held the reins at Valley Parade between 2010-11, he was commuting from his Essex home. He apparently stayed down South during the week, with others taking the training. Taylor came up to West Yorkshire in the middle of the week and of course for matchdays. Whatever the rights and wrongs of that arrangement, it isn’t a model many City supporters will want to see repeated.

When Duff holds his first official press conference, our local media should be rightly asking how it will work at City. Hopefully it’s a pretty satisfactory, boring answer. No one needs Duff’s home address. No one needs to know which colour bin he’s putting out each week. But we do want some reassurance he’s committed to being present.

It feels slightly weird that where Bradford City’s manager chooses to sleep should be any of our business. But it kinda is.

It will be a stick to beat Duff with if things are going wrong.

What does this appointment say about the club?

For too many years, managerial changes at Valley Parade have brought lurches in direction. One manager builds a squad to play one way, the next wants something different, and another expensive rebuild begins.

This time, City appear to have appointed a manager to fit what they already have.

That matters.

Duff inherits players accustomed to operating with three centre-backs, wing-backs, aggressive pressing and relatively direct football. He inherits a successful team rather than a failing one. Whatever tweaks he ultimately makes, there should be no urgent need to dismantle the principles that have served City so well.

That feels important. The biggest mistake City could make after losing Alexander would be to behave as though everything Alexander built had left with him.

It also suggests a welcome degree of confidence in the structure that is already in place. City don’t need a saviour. They don’t need someone arriving with a grand five-year plan and demanding a completely different squad. They need a manager capable of taking something that is working and keeping it working.

That may not make for the most exciting managerial appointment. But after the upheaval of losing Alexander at the top of League One, perhaps exciting isn’t what Bradford City need.

Choosing Duff suggests they understand that.

Whether he can make continuity translate into continued success is the gamble that comes next.



Categories: Opinion

Tags: ,

43 replies

  1. It’s a good appointment.

    Not least because Duff got the best out of Phillips during his time at Barnsley.

  2. regarding Peter Taylor he rented a house in Bingley and was seen drinking in the local pubs with Lawn on numerous occasions. On Duff I think I would rather live in the heart of the Cotswolds than Bradford. It’s not a very hard decision. His life at all his clubs apart from Cheltenham was between 5 and 11 months which doesn’t bear well. A bad appointment and City supporters should be asking where the £500k for GA and the £200k for his assistant has gone? As it’s not been spent on acquiring the out of work Duff has it.

    • I’m sure we’d all like to think that we’ll see the compensation money being used in January on a new signing or 2?

      • why would the board do that? They have spent about £500k from the Metcalfe money who they sold too cheap at about £1.5million.

        They also have the cup run money which is also somewhere?

      • I’m not an expert on our budget and finances but I think we probably have spent at least half of the Metcalfe money on transfer fees and maybe budgeted the rest to cover salaries or to save for Jan?

        Philips- £300k

        Beesley – £150k-£200k

        O’Keefe – £100k-£150k

        Gillesphey – Rumoured to be a Nominal fee

        Cartwright – Rumoured to be a Nominal Fee

        I agree £1.5m feels low considering we know how good Metcalfe’s potential is but for us I think the money was too good to turn down, especially given if we kept him he’d have 1 year left next summer.

        With the league cup, there’s no prize money and we’ve made around £10,000 so far on shared ticket sales; we actually lost money by having to go to London and play Orient in front of a tiny crowd.

        Let’s see if we sign anyone in January or the summer and pay a significant fee for him.

      • on top of this I wouldn’t expect we received the Metcalfe money in one hit either

      • I’m always perplexed as to how supporters know what the wage bill is, how much money was received in transfers and what each individual player is on. As far as I’m aware much of this stuff is not in the public domain (but I could be wrong). In addition I’m pretty sure transfer money comes in, and out, in dribs and drabs rather than in big one off payments.

        That’s not to say we shouldn’t expect some transparency in the finances at Valley parade but rather that the situation is more complex than one might imagine at first glance.

        Also – point to note – Google maps is wrong. I live in Cheltenham and I would love to get back to Bradford in 3.5 hours. In my experience 4 is the bare minimum and it can easily take longer.

    • It’s not as simple as ‘what comes in is available to spend on players’.

      The club is a business at the end of the day and running costs are expensive. Last year we lost £3m, the year before £1m and by all accounts, we’re a much stronger squad this season, and that means higher wages.

      You can’t simply tot up incoming/outgoing transfer fees to balance the books… I’m sure the board would love if it was that simple.

      The Metcalfe money, GA compensation, and big Mbanq sponsorship money help us mitigate the extra spending while balancing the books.

      I’m sure there will be room to manoeuvre in January should we need to improve, like if the new gaffer can’t get a tune out of Humphrys either – he’s on a big salary by all accounts, so moving him on alone would provide substantial funds in saved wages.

      • we are a club who has one of the biggest turnovers in the league with a top 3 crowd after Leicester and Wednesday who have bigger wage budgets also. The constant narrative of not having any money is consistently being spun is bollocks. We have spent anywhere near what Buzby is saying as Phillips was in his last year and O’Keefe was not a Barnsley regular. We sold Metcalfe cheaply to enable us to spend about £500k this summer. We obviously pay Rupp his dividend and the ground rent

      • Just saw the comment Jimmy, so I know it’s a bit late to reply but wanted to show my working out.

        Of course, I’ve no insider knowledge on how much we paid for any of our players.

        The £300k estimate was down to the figures I got from some online research.

        Phillips market value was around £650k according to Transfermarket but other websites like FootballTransfers put his value between £400k-£500k, but because he had 1 year left on his deal we could get him for around 40%-50% less than his market value.

        Local reports and industry insiders suggested we’d paid around £300k-£350k to Barnsley to secure his signing. But, this might have been less if we were working off the market value around £400k-£500k.

        I put the £300k mark as that’s what the reports and insiders suggested we’d paid and seemed reasonable for a proven league 1 attacking midfielder who had got 10+ goal contributions every season for 4 years.

        Might have been less and I hope we got him for less.

  3. I imagine the things being said here and elsewhere in support of Duff’s appointment are basically what he has said to get the job.  Football management is a difficult job and it’s very easy to get the sack for any number of reasons.  All that said, Duff’s last two clubs have sacked him after about 12 months in charge, with all the upheaval and expense that goes with it.  No one knows at this stage whether this is a good appointment. Time will tell.  It may be that we have genuinely got the best possible candidate for the money we are offering and that other candidates with better CVs were not interested in our terms. 

    Arguably he may be able to see and do things the previous manager was blind to because he, Alexander, wished to persist with players and systems that had previously brought success. The new manager might sensibly conclude, for instance, that maintaining the status quo will not improve the scoring rate, which is particularly poor. I wish Mr Duff the best of luck  with Bradford City and, indeed, Bradford City the best of luck with him.  All managers and all clubs need it.

  4. Church service

  5. If confirmed, essentially I wish Mr Duff well. My hope is that the Club have addressed his living in Cheltenham, & are about to appoint him assured that there is no issue with this arrangement. Much of the article I do agree with, & rather than judge his abilities without a ball being kicked, Im more than happy to see how these coming weeks & months go.

    Our previous manager has moved on now, & I wish him well at Preston. But this is another chapter that is just about to start, & I hope another very happy & successful one.

    Welcome to Bradford city Michael.

    Up the Bantams!

  6. Unless a prospective manager is prepared to live in the.aeea ( not Manningham) i would not beven consider apointing Duff or anybody.

    Its smacks of short termism or a lack of full.commitment.

    GA travelled from the Fylde coast and that was far enough.

    Cheltenham?

    Daily in the forthcoming bad weather and dark nights and early mornings!!!

    Forget it!!

    i thought City would have learned their lesson with Tilt, Power and Walker.

    Irrespective of any impressive interview, appointing Duff without such commitment would be a poor one.

    • I’ve no idea, why you think that he would be commuting from Cheltenham daily.

      That’s at least 8hrs travel time (there and back and I’ve done it) and you think the boards of Barnsley, Huddersfield and us are bonkers enough to agree to that?

      i.e. you really think for his previous posts he got up at 2am and got back home for 10pm three / four days a week.

      • Sheffield United allowed Neil.Warnock to.manage whilst living South of Penzance.

        Of course I realise he would not travel.daily but apart from taking training there are several.other reasons to be bases nearby.

  7. i don’t think Duff will be offerred a 3 year contract. Likely, to be 1 year or 18 months. Don’t think he will change anything straightaway. I would expect City Board would want him to live within the Yorkshire area. I would be interested who he appoints as his assistant. Cound be Trueman!

    I would hope (like Alexander) he would get the best out of his players. I wounder if his team selection will be similar to Alexander’s. Is he going to make changes in his selection? I thought Alexander use of Powell was exceptional and considering he is one of our leading scorer as a substitute. Hope he doesn’t change that arrangement. Best of luck Duff – give it your all.

    • For the umpteenth time City dont have a board.

      We have a sibgle owner who.operates his ckub through a CEO.

  8. Not excited ,very average and hasnt held a job down for a few years , he will be gone by Christmas and Stuart bless him will be back

  9. Excellent article – suspect David Sharpe is key person in choice of new manager, if so trust his judgement…

  10. As with many managerial appointment you can probably make just as many arguments for why it’s a good one vs why it’s a bad one, but, only time will tell.

    I wasn’t excited about the prospect of Duff until Alex on the WoaP podcast laid out the case for him, in that he made Barnsley one of the best attacking, high pressing and high energy teams in league 1 – You can see this in their 2nd goal here against Sheffield Wednesday back in 22/23: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EHQZbgE2rKI

    Now, he got Barnsley to 4th with the 5th biggest budget in the league and they lost to Wednesday in the play off final, but, it’s worth highlighting that Wednesday had a budget around £4m bigger than Barnsley and Barnsley took them all the way. He got Cheltenham 1st in league 2 with the 17th biggest budget and 15th in league 1 with around the 21st biggest.

    Since Barnsley, he hasn’t had successes but at Huddersfailed and Wycombe you can argue both sacking were harsh. He was dismissed at Huddersfield after they’d only won 4 times in 15 matches but had massive injuries and were still 6th. For comparison, of our last 15 matches of last season, including the play offs, Alexander only won 5 times and we all remember Parkinson’s 13 game winless run in 13/14, however, those managers had a supportive network around them and credit int he bank. Would Duff be shown the same faith if he endured such a run this season? Additionally at Wycome he had 3 draws and 2 losses from the first 5 games but they were against some of the best teams in the division, Plymouth, Stockport and Wednesday; although their form tailed off from around Easter last season when they had an outside chance of the play offs.

    We are led to believe he’s got a similar style to Alexander, honest, direct and firm but fair. Plus, he’d had success in this league playing 3 at the back and a high press, high energy system.

    On the point of his family living in Cheltenham, I would imagine he’ll rent somewhere up here and travel down to see them. I know many of us can’t imagine this lifestyle but in particular industries it is commonplace. Look at Slot at Liverpool, his family stayed in the Netherlands and he rented a place in Liverpool, I know Mourinho has done the same living in hotels with his family elsewhere. Away from the elite of football, we have a family friend who’s lived in Ireland but he worked in Bradford Monday to Friday and then travelled back on the weekend to be with them. He’s done that for about 16 years on far less money than Duff will be on, if it is right for all parties people will make it work. Yes, if Duff is doing very well and he can get a job closer to home on better money will he take it? Yes, definitely… But, that means we’ll be in a good place too.

    Given the other options available I can see why the club have gone for him, he’s got experience of the division and should be a good cultural fit.

    I hope for him and for us it works out but regardless of how it pans I can understand why the club have gone for him.

    • Slot and Mourinhio were managers of PL clubs which is light years away from.Bradford City.

      Even putting up.Duff in an hotel, or giving him a flat for several.nights a week is a major cost.

      i feel.its an unrealistic to manage a club.

      it didnt work at Barnsley or Huddersfield and there is no reason why it would work here.

      • Of course but it’s all relative to the level of manager and clubs… maybe I’m naive but at Duff’s level would he not be expected to pay his own rent for a flat/house? Or if we pay it would an extra £8k-12k a year be that significant for us to pay, if he rented out a property? Hypothetically, if Duff works out, would any of hs complain about paying that on top of his salary?

        Not sure how you can argue it didn’t work out at Barnsley when they were in the play off final and finished on 86 points and then he got a championship job off the back of that season. Huddersfield it didn’t end well for Duff but many Huddersfield fans said it was a harsh sacking.

      • cheer up mate we’ve been in worse scenarios over the last 10 years!

  11. For all the reasons you set out, Duff seems a good choice from who is available in these circumstances, though I guess you could argue that could have given Trueman a go with Sharpe in support.

    At very least i hope Duffs appointment is conditional on keeping Trueman & Doyle.

  12. Maybe fans need to go back and read the archived article when we appointed GA! Look at the comments, and look how it ultimately turned out.

    https://widthofapost.com/2023/11/06/football-club-finally-appoints-football-manager-as-graham-alexander-unveiled-as-new-bradford-city-boss/

  13. Many thanks for an excellent analysis, Jason , and a reassuring one for what might on first glance seem an underwhelming appointment but remember GA’s CV also underwhelmed with apparent failures at Salford and MK Dons.

    Thank goodness we seem to have passed the stage where we appoint managers carelessly without realising the full long term costs of appointing those with completely different styles and approaches from the last one.

    I’m sure Michael Duff will want to prove Huddersfield , Barnsley and Wycombe were badly wrong in upcoming matches by end of November!

    • TBF to Barnsley they did not want him to leave and Michael recognises now he should not have left after just one year, despite the offer from a Championship club. In reality this gives him the chance to go back to 2023 and take City onto the season Barnsley might well have had if he had stayed a further year. Barnsley in 2023 were a very good team. Bradford City in 2026 are a very good team. Onto Michael to use all of his 10 years in coaching and 8 years in management to not only maintain Graham’s approach and success, but to better it ! I predict he will !

      • One of my best friends is a Barnsley fan and states that it was a lack of ambition from the board, which has continued for the last three seasons, that resulted in Duff looking around and rather desperately taking the Swansea job – a club totally unsuited.

        Interestingly my friend was praying that we took on Heckingbottom, who got Barnsley promoted in 2016 (via the play-off against the Millwall team that beat us in the SF) as he doesn’t rate him as high as Duff.

        Looking forward to chatting to him when Duff is announced.

  14. Well, after all that, I’m officially talking myself into it!

    Duff might not have arrived with the glamour factor, but the fit makes a lot of sense. If he can keep the good bits, add his own touch and avoid making us all reach for the panic button, we could be onto something.

    Welcome to Bradford, Michael. Now go and prove us all wrong. Up the Bantams

  15. We should all be grateful that the decision about the new manager was not ours to make because it’s never straightforward. Besides you have the court of experts and hindsight to account to. Whether it is Duff or A.N.Other, this has been a difficult decision and we have to get behind those who make it. Comments on WOAP testify that there are diverse opinions and none of us can say with certainty what will happen until it does.

    Previously we have put our hopes in finding an exceptional manager to overcome the constraints at Valley Parade. However in the background there have been major changes to the way that the club is run.  Those foundations are now much stronger than anything known previously by any living supporter. 

    The key point is that the constraints facing a new BCAFC manager are much reduced and as a result, he has a greater chance of success. I’d argue that the manager himself is much less the critical factor than previously. Likewise, strong foundations make any business better more robust and that is definitely the case at Valley Parade now than say five years ago.

    The club has momentum and a good squad upon which to build. Duff’s impact will ultimately have more to do with winning the hearts and minds of the dressing room than being expected to make changes. In turn this is a luxury that preceding managers have not enjoyed.

    Irrespective of opinions he deserves our support and we have a vested intetest in getting behind him.

  16. I wonder why it is taking so long to confirm. Is there a sticking point?

  17. Maybe talking to another club! Its a shorter distance to Stoke ( Port Vale) than to Bradford.

    • Or a contractual issue to resolve te travelling expenses?! Just waiting for an answer from banbroview to mediate and confirm Duff can lodge at his house during the week.

  18. what i can never understand about football managers is how one dimensional they are. They have to play a certain style or get players who can. Why can’t they be savvy enough to see what they have and choose a style that will suit. And if they fall out with a player rather than sort it out, they like to make an example of them. Just to show who’s the boss. It’s not really management. i wouldn’t give someone who lives 200 miles away the job anyway. Fingers crossed 🐓

  19. Well I’m now definitely in the “I’m totally fine with Duff camp” Personally, I’ve taken the time to read all that I can on his management background, comments by fans of his previous clubs and various forum write ups. He is not unpopular with a lot of fans from previous management jobs and many claim he has been treated harshly in a number of instances.

    Above all else, I do trust the senior management team at City to have done their due diligence with this appointment. The main point being – we’re a club truly heading in the right direction and only need to keep it steady rather than searching for a new manager as a complete basket case club looking to turn things upside down!

    Time will tell but I’m quietly confident that this appointment may well turn up trumps in the long run. Another point that I keep going back to is – previous good City managers that did a great job for us that didn’t get everyone universally excited when they started in BD8.

    In honesty, despite us being at the top end of Leagure 1, we may not have attracted a lot of the names that were apparently thrown into the ring anyway and I’m guessing some were purely Bookie’s guesses with no actual substance. In other words, some supporters may think City have not pushed the boat out when the truth might be that we didn’t have the pool of stand out candidates to pick from that some might think we had.

    Each to their own opinion on Duff and this is mine. I’ll be backing him to succeed!

    Welcome to City Michael (provided you do sign and not leg it after reading too much antisocial media!)

  20. It’s not the appointment I was hoping for but I guess I can see the argument in favour of hiring him.

    There’s actually another positive angle that hasn’t been mentioned in that Duff and GA are good friends.

    And the fact that this is a rare occasion where a manager is coming into a successful environment where the system isn’t broke or need tampering with…

    Means he can continue from where GA left off – which is the point everyone is making…

    However, the fact the new and old gaffers are good buddies, and the fact Duff doesn’t need to quickly search for a solution to ‘save the club’ from spiralling… also means he can get on to the ‘dog and bone’ to have a good chinwag with his old buddy.

    Where no new manager would dare admit, or even consider contacting the previous boss for advice… because these two are best pals and the club are already going in the right direction…

    GA can give Duff the full blueprint and every single detail about, training, philosophy, positional nuances, player insights, and everything else.

    Not that I’m suggesting Duff can’t (or won’t be able to) think for himself… but as well as being given the job on the basis of continuity.. should he want, he can contact GA at anytime for help with staying as close to what we’ve had for the past couple of years.

    Which gives him an extra feather to his bow than just “he plays with a back three and likes to press”.

    Time will tell I guess. The one other good thing I can think of is that Duff signed Adam Phillips – or at least they both joined Barnsley at the same time and by all accounts, he had a good season with them.

    The sooner he starts, the better so if it’s all decided, then let’s just get him in so we can move on.

  21. Don’t want more of the same holding out for a 1-0 win after scoring after 4 minutes . We need someone who can get us scoring goals and put teams to the sword . Hope I’m wrong but if the results don’t come the fans will quickly turn . If mid table at Xmas he will be gone and the money we got for GA and CL will be used to pay him off .Not impressed by this appointment . Shambles