When character goes missing


Bradford City 2

Stead 10, Routis 50

Fleetwood Town 2

Procter 86, Pond 90

Saturday 21 March, 2015

By Jason McKeown (images by Thomas Gadd, see note below)

There has been so much positive about Bradford City’s season so far. But the missing ingredients are becoming increasingly evident; and these shortcomings are threatening to damage the ending.

However much a promotion push wasn’t expected last summer and even up until the autumn, it would now be a major disappointment if City were to stumble on the home straight in their fight for the play offs. If the final few games became a damp squib. If the close season was spent agonising over the mounting what-ifs.

This game was all about setting the tone for the final 10 matches. And with four minutes left on the clock, the prospect of defeating a play off rival offered a major confidence boost to take into the business end of the season. But then the Bantams conspired to chuck away a two-goal and two points, and the momentum has slipped further. Suddenly, the form guide reads one win in nine matches. Not the stuff upon which late promotion charges are made of.

‘What if’ indeed. This was maddening. City were complacent, City were careless, and at the final whistle City were crestfallen. 2-0 up and absolutely cruising. Fleetwood had long ago hoisted the white flag. They were out for the count, happy to see out time without incurring further damage. And home fans were starting to head home to beat the traffic, satisfied by their team’s endeavours.

There was nothing more to see here.

Suddenly a poorly conceded goal made it 2-1. Yet it still looked no more than a Fleetwood consolation. City would surely see it out. There was no real pressure that followed from the visitors. And though the gasps that followed the announcement there would be five minutes of injury time demonstrated that nerves within the stadium were growing, it still seemed a routine exercise in running down the clock. City were too superior.

But then a scramble, feeble attempts by home players to clear their lines and Nathan Pond was on hand to equalise for the Cod Army. Pond has been at Fleetwood for 12 years, during which he has made over 300 appearances and being part of six Fleetwood promotion-winning sides – a world record. From part-time footballer in the North West Counties League to a third tier player, Pond’s never-say-die attitude offered an interesting contrast to his opponents’ meek surrender.


There were boos from a healthy 12,000+ Valley Parade crowd. The frustration magnified by the fact we have been here before this season, far too often. The conceding of stoppage time goals has already occurred against Gillingham, Scunthorpe United, Rochdale and Port Vale. Late equalisers were also conceded against Walsall and Notts County.

That’s now 13 points dropped from late winning positions. If City had retained even half of those points, they’d currently be sat in the play offs.

The arguments will rage over how this same painful Fleetwood ending occurred. The choice and timing of substitutions was blamed by some, and Phil Parkinson held his hands up after the game to admit he got them wrong. Yet he is entitled to have expected more from those who came onto the field late on and who let him down, and he is also entitled to demand 90-minute performances from those who stayed on the field.

It was a collectively failing; although you can see why substitutes Andy Halliday, Matt Dolan and Francois Zoko have more to hold their hands up for. Halliday’s stock amongst supporters has mysteriously dropped of late and perhaps he has not handled his recent demotion to the bench in the most productive manner. He was either fouled or easily bullied off the ball in build up for Fleetwood’s first goal; and throughout his cameo seemed caught in two minds between sitting alongside Gary Liddle or charging into the box.

But that was nothing on the other two, and Dolan was especially maddening. As I said, initially after Fleetwood’s first goal there seemed no danger of them completing a comeback, as City continued to dominate possession. They won a corner late on and Dolan and Zoko raced over to take it short and keep the ball near the corner flag. Inexplicably, Dolan swung a lazy-looking cross into the box where no one in claret and amber was based, and from there Fleetwood attacked and the pattern of the game changed in their favour.

What is going on here, Matty? You clearly have plenty of talent, otherwise you wouldn’t have reached this point in your career. But do you really want to be a professional footballer? Do you think the standards you showed today were acceptable? We know you can do so much better, and it is deeply frustrated to watch you play so casually and without thought. Your livelihood is on the line here. The drop to non-league football is not as far away as it seems. Just ask Pond.

As for Zoko, he wasted a big opportunity at 2-1 when he took the wrong option, and soon after produced brilliant bit of skill but failed to get a shot on goal. And then at 2-2, Zoko had a glorious, glorious chance to right his team’s wrongs and reclaim the three points. He screwed his shot badly wide.

He is not the player we need him to be. I get that Zoko tries – he does – but the bar is rising all the time at Valley Parade and he is falling short of it.


Had Zoko scored, the outlook would have been completely different and more fitting with what we actually saw on the field. Because make no mistake, for 86 minutes City were very good here. They outplayed a side who might not be easiest on the eye, but who are wily, talented and in the play off shake-up on merit.

The Bantams played some impressive football at times, and the story of the day was set to be that of the three midfielders in the diamond who had been overlooked for the Reading game last Monday – Billy Clarke, Mark Yeates and Christopher Routis.

Clarke was especially unfortunate to start on the bench at the Madjeski, and he underlined what a difference he might have made in the FA Cup replay with some outstanding pieces of football. I am a big fan of Clarke. I love his intelligence and craft on the ball, the fact he picks out passes that those of us in the crowd don’t spot, and the way he can glide past defenders with the ball seemingly tied to his boot.

Clarke personifies better than anyone the fruits of Parkinson’s summer revamp to the squad. Previous City managers would have scratched their heads on where to play someone like Clarke.They’d have given him a role where he couldn’t shine,and then found it easy to leave him on the sidelines. But Parkinson has got the best out of Clarke, and his link up play with those around him is a joy to behold. He is no leader, but he makes people around him play better.

It was from Clarke’s excellent charge into the box and low cross from where City took an early lead. Town’s goalkeeper Chris Maxwell mis-handled the ball, allowing Jon Stead to squeeze the rebound home. City were rampant in those early stages. Yeates enjoying his best performance in a long time. Routis and Clarke came close to doubling the lead.


Routis has experienced a rollercoaster first season in English football, and has certainly come a long way since I first saw him on trial for a Bradford City XI at Ossett Town last July. His calmness on the ball and passing ability always suggested the Frenchman could have a big future, but his composed style has not always proven the right approach for a League One defender.

After his harrowing afternoon as centre back at Oldham last October, Routis has been held back and re-invented into a midfielder. Playing on the right of the diamond here, Routis was very impressive. Like Clarke he links up well with team mates and is mastering the late run into the box from the opposite side.

Routis almost got in a couple of occasions earlier, and then just after half time he timed his run to perfection and converted James Hanson’s cross at the back post. 2-0, and cruise control.

It wasn’t that City let up from that point on – they really didn’t – but perhaps beyond the obvious post-match criticisms about failing to see out games, a more long-term shortcoming was revealed. Because the truth was that City should have been out of sight before the closing stages. They lack a ruthless edge in front of goal.

I like Stead, and I like Hanson, but neither are prolific goalscorers. And the fact there isn’t a prolific goalscorer on the books – a Nahki Wells – is hurting City’s progress. Only seven League One teams have scored fewer goals than the Bantams – and only Fleetwood, above them in the table, rank below in the ‘Goals For’ column.

There is a clamour to sign up Stead in the summer and I am firmly with these people. But how many goals are Hanson and Stead likely to collectively score over a full season? Would they match the 41 of Hanson and Wells in 2012/13? And though the rest of this team are much better at chipping in with goals compared to the History Makers side, it is a concern. Sign Stead up, but next season we will also need a striker who can push on towards 20 goals.

That is for another day, and certainly there isn’t much that can be done in the short-term to address the relative lack of goals. What is needed quickly is greater steel and resolve, so that slender leads are held rather than surrendered. So that in sticky situations, leaders rise and stand tall. Pointing the way for others to follow.

And therein lies the positives and shortcomings of Bradford City this season. We have improved significantly in the style of football played and the quality of the attacking players on show. Remember Parkinson’s first season and his insistence on playing two holding players in the centre of the park? Now we have the joys of Clarke and Billy Knott and Filipe Morais and Routis and Yeates conjuring up magical displays behind an intelligent front two pairing – and anchored by the steady hand of Gary Liddle.

But we don’t have the courage of Gary Jones and Nathan Doyle. The resoluteness of Garry Thompson and Will Atkinson. The doggedness of Ricky Ravenhill and Zavon Hines.

If Parkinson can readdress this balance some more, and ensure that City can mix the ugly side of things with the pretty, they can still mount a play off push this season. There are some huge games to come between now and the final outing at Crewe and the recent cup exploits can be an inspiration for handling these occasions.

But the team are going to have to demonstrate far greater character and resolve when things start going against them, in order to succeed in their bid to extend their season.

City: Williams, Darby, McArdle, MacKenzie, Meredith, Liddle, Routis (Dolan 79), Yeates (Halliday 72), Clarke, Hanson, Stead (Zoko 81)

Not used: Urwin, Sheehan, Knott, Mottley-Henry

With special thanks to the brilliant Thomas Gadd for allowing us to use his brilliant photos. Please visit Thomas Gadd’s website for more details or here to view more photos of this game.

Categories: Match Reviews

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

13 replies

  1. I felt sorry for Routis today. It’s a shame we are talking about two late goals conceded instead of his performance and goal.

  2. oh dear. ..the painful reminder we have one win in 9! looks like another season in league one beckons. 74 points needed ( last seven seasons except one to make playoffs ).can we win 8 out of 10? ,i wouldnt bet on it. then again, i wouldnt have bet on us against chelsea. we have the talent and ability. …yet without concentration and grit. .we deserve nothing more than what we give. dont give up on the lads yet. but for crying out loud. ……..WAKE UP BOYS!!!

  3. Unfortunately I missed the game yesterday due to work commitments. I am doubly disappointed that we did not hold on for the win but that I fid not get to see Routis for a prolonged run out. I have only seen little snippets of him to date.

    Thankfully your excellent write up has helped me picture what sort of player he can become for City. He is a really promising player and I hope PP can include him more often so that he does not get itchy feet. We already have a small squad so losing any defensive players who are also comfortable on the ball is not desirable. He could be a player that looks better if we get promoted, where the opposition style allows ball players to show there stuff.

    So hoping that the team can turn it round in the next game and lay down a big message for the remaining ten games, akin to two years ago where we clinched a play off spot from well back. We have games against Doncastor and Barnsley coming up during that run which are 6 pointers.
    Come on City 👏👏

  4. There is no disguising the fact that the performance yesterday was below par but we should not under estimate the after effects of the cup run and the disappointment of the Reading game. The experience last Monday hurt all of us and inevitably it will have impacted on confidence and self belief. I suspect that many of the players are physically and mentally drained so the planned holiday in Portugal could be a good investment. Of course I’d like the team to be in the play=offs and promoted at Wembley once more but suspect that we need to manage our expectations. As Jason says, our hopes have been raised but it would be sad if the season was season as a disappointment if we failed to make the play offs.

    On a separate note, thanks to all who supported the Bantamspast Bradford Pals initiative yesterday which proved very successful – details to follow.

  5. Spot on once again Jason.failure to score anywhere near enough goals to reflect our long periods of dominance. this gives the opposition hope, and more than hope. then the inability to hold onto the small lead we do have.. the panic in the six yard box with the pall pinging around as if in a pinball machine and the inevitability as you just know it’s going to end up in our net. you rightly mentioned the three subs but I must say that my doubts about the keeper are growing. he is weak and doesn’t come anywhere near dominating his six yard box. we do badly need a regular goalscorer. hanson or stead definitely do enough to play alongside such a striker but I agree…..the two of them together won’t score us enough goals to make up for the frontman we lack.

  6. Good work again Jason!

    I agree that we need a striker who is going to get somewhere near 20 goals but the problem is so does everybody else! We don’t have the money to be able to buy a striker like this unfortunately so I suspect we will have to settle with a striker with less proven track record in front of goal and hope we can get him to push on!

    To be honest I am not sure we are ready for the championship (that said it’s very rare that teams going up are comfortable their first season) with the current squad, I would say that maybe we have about 5 or 6 in the squad that may be able to step up but the rest I think would struggle. I am not saying that we shouldn’t be going for it but I think we could be in for a rocky ride if we did!

  7. My tuppence worth is that I thought Ben Williams had a poor game. Lucky in the early part of the 2nd half when an attempted clearance from a cross led to goal line scramble. He just doesn’t want to grasp the opportunity of being our number 1 keeper. His kicking though improved seems suspect. Not sure why the Jan Alnwick wasn’t playing, is he injured?

    As for Zoko, he seemed to be knackered 5 mins after coming on and failed to close down the opposing players. Coupled to that the miss at the end which was criminal.

    As mentioned our substitutions seem to weaken the team rather than provide us with a 2nd wind.Finally, the Stead/Hanson partnership is not working. I think both give all for City but i would only play one of them at time. Love Hanson but I like to see the Stead/Clark partnership back which kick started our season a few months ago.

    • Stead/Hanson does not work and as Stead has far more to his game he should always be one of the first names on the team sheet. I agree that the Stead/Clark partnership worked very well during Hanson’s absence and given the players currently at the manager’s disposal this would be my favoured matchup. Having Knott and Yeates in the mix would hopefully see more variety to the play with less reliance on the long high ball.

  8. Can not understand why so many felt the need to Boo at the final whistle. This was a great disappointment not a disgrace and those who joined in have very short memories of what this team have achieved. It went badly wrong but for so long we were in control and playing well and the comeback goal that Zoko failed to take would have meant the reaction to the final whistle would have been oh so different.The players did not deserve the boos but do need the proverbial boot up the backside for surrendering such a lead.
    One point of deja vu… once again Zoko was up the steps to the changing room whilst the rest of the team were acknowledging the fans and this suggests he still has not grasped what has made these players a team. The miss is forgivable if hard to take but the disrespect to fans and teammates is not.

  9. All this talk of a goalscorer.
    In todays `Football League Paper` it lists the top goalscorers in all divisions but interestingly in League One Wilbraham and Dagnall share 24 goals (14 and 10 respectively). They were not good enough for us (Said the fans) when they were with us.
    Lets evolve and press our claim for the Championship when its right to do so, rather than get up and struggle, therefore sack the manager, and repeat the mistakes of previous campaigns.

%d bloggers like this: