By Jason McKeown
As the feel-good factor continues to swirl around Valley Parade, you don’t have to look too far for a Northern League One club with a very different outlook.
45 miles to the west of Bradford, Bolton Wanderers are currently enduring a difficult spell, with an initially promising start to the season turning into a long winless run only ended on Saturday with the help of a bizarre own goal. The Trotters – only relegated to League One last season and a Premier League club four years ago – are struggling to adapt to their new surroundings. And the man in charge is copping much of the blame.
And that is of great interest to Bradford City fans, given the background. Phil Parkinson’s shock decision to switch from Valley Parade to the Macron Stadium over the summer so far isn’t working out brilliantly for the Wanderers manager. Reading Bolton news websites offers a flavour of Parkinson’s struggle to impress, and suggests he is likely to come under increasing pressure. In June 2006 he quit Colchester United for Hull City but only lasted six months before he was sacked. His first challenge is to avoid history repeating itself.
Some City fans are gleefully enjoying his struggles, others have sympathy, but few of us are ignoring what is happening. The fortunes of Parkinson is a key narrative of our own season simply because of the huge impression he made at Bradford City over nearly five years in charge. One of the benchmarks of Bradford City’s success is how it compares to Bolton.
And on that front, it’s so far so very good. Stuart McCall’s return to Valley Parade has started out better than anyone could have dared hope. And whilst there is a long, long way to go and an ongoing need to keep feet on the ground, his appointment increasingly looks like an inspired move by the new owners Edin Rahic and Stefan Rupp.
Make no mistake, it wasn’t the obvious decision. There was a clear danger that recruiting Uwe Rosler to replace Parkinson would have look convoluted and left the German owners open to accusations they pushed a popular manager away to employ their own man. Steve Evans was also mooted and made clear his interest, but it would have divided the fanbase and eroded the spirit of the club. Neil Redfearn was the other main candidate, yet has a patchy track record at best.
Still, McCall risked being accused as a populist vote to appease fans who could have very easily turned on the unknown new owners if it didn’t work out. But despite some fans having misgivings initially, McCall has successfully united the football club and is building on Parkinson’s legacy. He has kept so much good of what Parkinson left behind, such as a rock solid defence and universal work ethic. And he has added to it with shrewd signings and a more attractive style of football.
It has so far been seriously impressive stuff from McCall. The contrast between what he has instilled this time around compared to his troubled first spell in charge is vast. He is a manager who has gone away and learned so much, built on his expertise, and developed a level of confidence that was lacking nine years ago. Watching the movement and interchanging of the players in the latter stages of the first half against Shrewsbury last week highlighted what an excellent technical coach he has become. We are playing football on another level to the past.
What it could lead to – it’s almost too exciting and emotional to want to talk about. Imagine if McCall could achieve the success that alluded him last time? He will always be a legend for what his heroics as a player, but his first period as manager hardly enhanced that standing. To come back and have another go – and this time deliver glory – would have you in tears of joy. We are so far off realising that reality and we shouldn’t allow ourselves to discuss it, but imagine what could lie in store…
The early success of McCall has been so important. It’s allowed the new owners time to settle in and put the wheels in motion of their long-term strategy, and for us supporters it has enabled us to quickly move on. No one will ever be able to take away what Phil Parkinson achieved at Bradford City, but waving goodbye to that era has been far easier than we’d have dared hope. Within a group of City-supporting friends of mine, someone recently posed the question – would you rather have Parkinson back? “No” was the majority response.
Whatever the rights and wrongs about the way Parkinson left City in the summer – not to mention his strangely unemotional behaviour during the recent league meeting – it increasingly looks obvious that it was the right time for him to have moved on. I’ve met Rahic only briefly but it’s very obvious that his approach and outlook is very different to Mark Lawn and Julian Rhodes, and it is one that Parkinson would have struggled to work under.
Chiefly it is about taking some of the control away from the manager over player recruitment. Rahic likes to have a say (so too did Lawn and Rhodes) but he has also built up a structure where other people influence who is signed. Parkinson would never have welcomed a Greg Abbott type of appointment. He had full control of transfers and the playing direction of the club, including in his last season having the strength to move away from calls to play attractive football.
Abbott had a big role in the summer’s transfer business and can share credit in the way almost everyone has enjoyed such a fast start to life at Valley Parade. In 2015, Parkinson’s incomings were largely disappointing and the season was rescued by more money being made available late on for the likes of Reece Burke, Lee Evans and Kyel Reid. Abbott will continue to have an increasingly important role at the club, and in theory will out-last McCall.
With Rahic’s desire for more young players to come through the ranks too, and the upfront playing budget being slightly lower than it was last season, you could understand why Parkinson decided the new direction wasn’t for him. And that clean break was ultimately right for Bradford City too. We should always be thankful for what Parkinson did for us; and, increasingly, the list of reasons of why we are grateful looks sets to include the timing of his departure.
The big issue for Parkinson is that there’s a risk he chose the wrong club. The sideways step to Bolton always seemed a strange one – you’d have thought he could have got a better job if he’d have held out – and the pressure he has been under recently suggests an unhappy ending could ultimately lie in store.
Bolton are at an earlier point in the cycle than Bradford City were when Parkinson took charge. They think they’re too big for their new surroundings, that their squad of players should dominate the league, and that their stay in the third tier should be a short one. Recent examples of Wolves and Wigan dropping only temporarily into League One before instantly winning promotion add weight to this outlook. They should be pushing on and – for Parkinson’s sake – will need to do so quickly.
Coincidentally McCall’s first period as manager came with City in similar circumstances – a first drop to League Two in a quarter of a century, and a widespread expectation we would walk the league. It didn’t work out that way, and McCall’s legendary status bought him more time than other managers would have enjoyed. But it was only after further years of League Two disappointment – and the failures of Peter Taylor and Peter Jackson – that it was accepted it was going to take time to turn the club around.
Which is what Parkinson got. In his first season at City he hardly pulled up any trees, but it enabled him to change the culture and embed his values, laying on the platform for the staggering History Makers success. If Bolton are patient with Parkinson, his track record shows they will be rewarded. But Bolton have no past history with Parkinson, and very little patience for a long-term building plan, and that could be his undoing.
That’s why it is so interesting to City fans. Whilst some supporters are currently staring intently at Bolton whilst munching popcorn, waiting for our old manager to fail, most of us are merely enjoying the comparison between the two clubs and the fact that – so far – we got the best of the deal.
Parkinson’s success at Bradford City meant the world because of the 12 years of misery that came before it. But as brilliant as the ride was 2011 to this summer, there was always a fear of what would happen to the club after Parkinson left. How dependant were we on him to move forwards? Would we go back to bad old ways as soon as he departed?
We know now that there is life after Parkinson – and in fact it could be even more wonderful. McCall is taking the club forwards and on this journey back up the leagues it feels like we’ve reached a new level. It might not last forever, and nothing is decided in October, but there is a real joy to be had about the way Bradford City are performing this season.
We’ve moved on, whereas the architect of the club’s revival is the one in danger of being left behind.
Vote for us
Width of a Post is a finalist at the Football Blogging Awards, if you like what we do, please click here or here to vote for us, or here for full details.
Excellent piece and despite all the plaudits that Stuart is rightly getting, i’m pleased that the work of Greg Abbott has been acknowledged too. Also, the strategy of Messrs Rahic & Rupp seems to be very interesting to see if their ‘German’ style model of doing things will work in English football. Edin stated very early that he wanted more from the development of young players at the club and the faith shown in the likes of Daniel Devine, Ellis Hudson, RWF & Kwame Boateng so far has been admirable. Its early days yet but it must surely encourage anyone in the youth department that there is a clear path to the first team at last. Its been a long time coming in my opinion. It will be interesting to see how far it goes if we manage to get promotion as it will be harder to integrate young players in a competitive side but its thrilling to see the club showing true faith in its youth at last. Add that to Abbo’s fantastic recruiting this year and i am more than happy with the future for the club.
Agreed, Abbo should always be mentioned when talking recruitment and if he is instrumental in scouting reports, has such an important role for our future success.
It is important that we enjoy our progress this season and it is inevitable comparisons are made with the previous regime and Bolton, but our progress has surprised many and Parkinson is likely to succeed given the time (which others seem to argue he hasn’t got time). I’d like to see Parky’s name not mentioned now until the end of the season when we can do a legitimate comparison, we are both “work in hand”.
I agree with your sentiments and comments, but really am no more interested in Bolton and Phil Parkinson than I am in any other club.
He left City because he wanted to leave, and has behaved cynically since then.
So let us leave him, thank him for what he did when he was here, and move on.
I know some fans were unhappy at PPs coldness towards the away section at the Bolton game, but I believe his behaviour was exactly I’d want to see if I was a BWFC fan.
Imagine if we’d ended up with that fat oaf Evans as manager. And imagine if we’d drawn L#@ds in the League Cup at home. How would you have reacted, as a City fan, if he’d walked out all waves and smiles to the rabble who follow them?
PP sent a clear message to the Bolton fans. He is 100% committed to them and their club. We’re just another team to compete against.
I think the most striking illustration of change at Bradford City happened yesterday. I just cannot image Danny Devine would have been played last year, let alone given a 3 year contract!
In other news, Bolton downgraded their Category One youth academy last year to save money. I am now most interested in Bolton because they look like they could be English football’s next train wreak.
I said at the season’s start that getting to the play-off’s would be a massive achievement for us, and I stick by that. Of course I want us to go up automatically (as f****** champions and all!), but it will not be crippling if we don’t.
For Bolton, on the other hand, not going up would be crippling. If they sack Parkinson soon, and still fail to get promoted, things could get so bad that administration and closure of their academy could be on the cards.
I think that Bolton will stick by Parkinson, because of his track record with City. Not just the success he brought, but also, when times were tough (like our 21 game win-less run and the start to last season) Parky pulled us out of it. That may be one of the defining factors that made them choose Parky? Maybe the Bolton board didn’t expect to walk it in this league? Maybe they expected a fight and a tough road ahead? And needed a leader who’d be strong during the tough times to help pull them out of what has been several seasons of slump.
Bolton have had a ‘wobble’ and Saturdays win over Swindon may well see a change in fortunes. The true character of our former manager has been forged in just such trying circumstances and if the Bolton board want any example of what he can achieve, they only need to look at last season, when we too had a ‘wobble’ but came through to finish in the play-off places.
On the other hand we’ve yet to taste defeat, less a bad run of results. That will be the true test of Stuart’s, the team’s and our owner’s character. And indeed the fans patience with what collectively City are trying to achieve over the longer term. Will we crumble (like Coventry did last season) or will we bounce back like we did last season? Will City fans continue to back the youth and playing philosophy if results don’t go our way?
So, while some City fans may revel in the supposed misfortunes of Bolton and our ex-manager, I only look on and think ‘there but for the grace of God go I’. There is a long, long way to go in the season and Bolton fans may well have the opportunity to revel in our own bad run of results.
Im not one for bragging about how bad our old manager is supposedly doing at Bolton. For a team struggling and not having fans on their side, they are doing great in my opinion in 4th position.
Im sure many teams would prefer where Bolton are at the moment
For me though the line if we could would I have Parky back the answer would have to be no and that’s all Because of Stuart and his team
The King is Dead, Long Live the King
The special one is gone its a new era with our new special one: Ginger Mourinho
Another superb article Jason. Your writing is maturing like McCall’s managerial skills.
At the moment it is easy to say that we are doing better than Bolton Wanderers on the pitch. However, let’s look at the final league table on 30 April 2017.
Having visited the Macron Stadium last month, I think that all Bradford City supporters prefer our style of play this season compared too last season. As much as I still supported Parkinson last season, I wasn’t enjoying our football and as I said then, I was shocked that we ended up in the play offs.
Like you say, time moves on and maybe this summer was the right time for Parkinson to leave us.
I will be forever grateful for Parkinson’s fantastic contribution to our football club.
Great article as always.
Some outstanding recruitment in such a short space of time in the summer leaves me really looking forward to see who we may sign in the next window.