Bury vs Bradford City preview
@Gigg Lane on Saturday 8 April
By Jason McKeown
It’s getting tight, very tight.
On Tuesday night, Millwall’s win at Shrewsbury has seen the pair close the gap on the Bantams, whilst Rochdale’s thumping of Port Vale means they still can’t be fully discounted. Oxford are all but out of it, but their Wednesday home defeat to Fleetwood means the Cod Army are now three points ahead of the Bantams. On a more positive note Southend were beaten 1-0 at home to Bolton on Tuesday (ending a run of four straight wins).
Prior to last week’s victory over Walsall, Stuart McCall suggested three more City wins might be enough to seal a play off finish. But if Millwall keep winning, and Scunthorpe and Southend get back to winning ways, at least three more wins might still be needed on top of defeating the Saddlers.
The midweek League One results have further emphasised just how vital the win over Walsall was. Another victory at Gigg Lane will take City a step closer to sealing an extension to the end of the season, a defeat could leave them hanging on the edge.
Bury will be desperate for the points too. Whilst Shrewsbury’s defeat to Millwall would have been cheered the Shakers, as it kept them three points above the bottom four, Lee Clark’s side still need a couple of victories to ensure League One football next season.
This is a big game.
Key games elsewhere
Like City, Southend, Millwall, Fleetwood and Rochdale are on the road this weekend with trips to sides in and around Bury in the lower reaches of the division.
The Shrimpers are at Charlton, who continue to flatter to deceive, whilst Millwall are at a Gillingham side in poor form (no clean sheet in last 19 games). 13 miles away from City’s game at Bury, Fleetwood will be at 19th-placed Oldham. Rochdale go to a Shrewsbury side winless since the middle of February.
Meanwhile Scunthorpe United welcome second-place Bolton to Glanford Park. None of City’s play off rivals have straightforward fixtures.
Expect a surprise or two.
It’s been another difficult season for Bury, who started the campaign impressively and were 2nd in the league when they came to Valley Parade in the CheckaTrade Trophy at the start of October. A club record 12 straight defeats followed, sending them into the bottom four, but under Clark they have bounced back to climb out of the relegation zone.
Bury have the worst defence in the division, which should offer encouragement to Stuart McCall’s men. But their attack isn’t bad and they’ve scored more goals than City themselves. Signing the injury-plagued James Vaughan in the summer looked to be a huge gamble, but the former Everton man has managed to stay fit and banged in 22 goals for Bury. Only Billy Sharp has outscored him this season.
Bury have the fifth-worst home record in League One – they tend to either win or lose rather than draw. When they came to Valley Parade in December they were just at the end of that wretched run. Four wins from the last 10 games is helping them to crawl towards safety.
The team selection talking points
After the mixed success of playing so open in the last away game at Scunthorpe, will McCall be brave again and play a 3-4-3? Or will he – more likely – continue last weekend’s 4-2-1-3 formation against Walsall that saw greater solidity?
It probably depends on whether Billy Clarke – who scored the winner last week, but was poor – keeps his place or if McCall opts to bring the fit-again Nicky Law into the side. Charlie Wyke picked up an injury late on against Walsall but was able to finish the game. There is a growing focus on Wyke’s failure to score away from Valley Parade so far. A Wyke goal at Gigg Lane would be very welcome.
The pre-match debate: Would you prefer Romain Vincelot play in defence and midfield?
WOAP writers share their views
“I’m going to throw this out there, neither! I don’t think he offers as much defensively and not technically as good or quick enough in midfield. I’d go with a midfield of Law, Dieng, Cullen and leave the defence as a four.” Tom Swithinbank
“It depends on whether we’re better suited playing a back three or back four in a certain game. Having someone who can switch between the two gives us so many more options tactically.” Tim Penfold
“I’d have Vincelot in defence. I think Cullen, Dieng and Law are better options in midfield, but I think Vincelot is a better player than McArdle and I think we’d miss his leadership if he wasn’t in the team. I also think he makes Knight-Percival a better player.” Nikhil Vekaria
“It’s difficult to get away from that fact that our defensive record was better when Vincelot was partnering Knight-Percival at CB. People voiced concerns about him being dominated in the air but he stood up well to this threat when required, Bolton away bring a prime example. Knight-Percival’s individual form was also better when he partnered Vincelot compared with when he’s been partnering McArdle. I think that this had a lot to do with Vincelot being more of an organiser and a talker than Rory.
“Having said all that, I’m not one of these people who is finding fault with Vincelot’s midfield performances, and I do think that our midfield looks better with him in there. All in all I think his versatility is vital in us being able to adapt and change formation during games. He’s an invaluable player to have and I only wish we could clone him.” Gareth Walker
“I’ve been fortunate to also play in two positions as a fan this season. Sometimes sitting in the upper Kop and mainly in the lower. I’m a fan of Vincelot at the back as the dimension of passing class is addressed from front to back, I was disappointed that he has been moved to midfield. From up high in the Kop it’s clear to see his legs whist they haven’t quite ‘gone’ take some time to get up to speed. This is particularly evident when he has to try chase an opposition player breaking away.
“When he was in defence he has the intelligence to give himself room to ‘play’ his opposition. Therefore, I think this is his best position. However, having said that Knight-Percival and to a lesser extent McArdle may not be the dominant type player he needs to play alongside him, particularly in this division. Here I’m talking physically robust rather than talkative. How great would a back two of Andrew Davies and Vincelot have been?
“Counter intuitively perhaps Vincelot may be better suited to playing at the back in the championship. I think he’d be well overrun in midfield.
“Meanwhile, in the base of the Kop it’s apparent how personally driven he is and how he encourages the team both vocally and behaviourally often giving his all and having the mental capacity to play his teammates games for them which leads to him dropping in to cover or blocking off opposition attacks in their infancy. In many sports maturity and intelligence can disguise a top athlete’s subsidiary physical decline for a while but the outcome is cast. Let’s hope he has his swan song with us next year playing centre back for City in the Championship.” David Lawrence
Reasons to worry
Bury have scored the opening goal in 12 of their 20 home games this season – and gone on to win 60% of those matches. City have only won one game away from home after the opponents scored first (at Northampton). If City go 1-0 down, be concerned.
Reasons to be optimistic
City have the third best away record in League One and will be able to count on a healthy City following to cheer them on. They’ve not failed to score in 15 games, netting in each of their last seven away matches.