
By Jason McKeown
Did you see the F1 Grand Prix at the weekend? Okay sorry, wrong audience. You’re here for Width of a Post, not Width of a Front Wing. This isn’t about Formula One. It’s about Bradford City.
Bear with me.
The Bahrain Grand Prix offered a fascinating lesson in what happens when a carefully prepared plan suddenly comes under pressure. And in a strange way, it might help explain why City are appointing Michael Duff.
(First of all, I’m definitely not an F1 expert. I watch enough to know who Kimi Antonelli is and not nearly enough to survive an argument with someone who owns a team cap. My technical understanding can be broadly summarised as: car go vroom vroom.)
Here’s what happened. For geopolitical reasons, the race was actually held in Malaysia, and heavy thunderstorms delayed its start by a couple of hours. As each F1 team examined the rain-sodden track that forecasts suggested would dry quickly, they had a big decision to make on what tyres to go with. Do you go for wet, dry, or intermediate (something in between)?
The majority of the teams decided to hedge their bets and go intermediate tyres.
But some, most notably Ferrari, did not. They elected for soft, dry tyres.
The race eventually began, and the impact of tyre choice was huge. Basically, everyone on intermediates flew out the traps. Those on soft did not. That included Ferrari’s Lewis Hamilton. He started second on the grid, and watched everyone fly past him. By the end of the opening lap, he’d dropped all the way down to 18th.
There’s the thing with sport, including football. Preparation is everything. The success of your plan is only measured when the action begins, and by then it’s often too late.
In football, so much goes into pre-season preparations and transfer windows, and when it all kicks off your course is largely set. We’ve seen plenty of Bradford City seasons where it goes badly and you can tell they were doomed by their pre-season. Equally, successful campaigns almost always have visible roots in the way the club planned in the summer before.
We can already see in Bradford City’s current season that they got the preparation right. The hard miles run in Austria, the number of new signings integrated before pre-season even began, and the player recruitment model itself all point to that. Reading away on Saturday offered some of the strongest confirmation yet that those foundations are robust. No Graham Alexander, same Bradford City. They look capable of moving forwards, even without their architect. Unlike Ferrari, the plan was working.
Back in Malaysia, Hamilton was looking doomed by the conditions. Ferrari suggested changing tyres, but he disagreed. If the track kept drying, his dry tyres would eventually become an advantage.
Hamilton reflected after. “We just had to stick with it. Like, we’ve made the decision and live with it.” Hamilton’s view was simple: the decision had been made. There was little to gain from chasing their tail and changing strategy.
At one stage race leader Kimi Antonelli was posting lap times 15 seconds faster.
But they’d made their call.
A clear parallel can be found here with Bradford City and their hunt for a replacement for Graham Alexander. Our history is full of managerial changes. And usually, it’s led to a change of strategy – often because the guy who’s just left is perceived to have failed. The idea behind recruiting them in the first place is now seen as a negative that must be abandoned.
We go for the opposite. Pragmatist to idealist. Young up and coming to experienced hand. Passionate to measured.
But in Michael Duff, City have tried to do something different by not doing something different. They recognised the qualities that made Alexander a success and looked for the closest available fit. This was City’s opportunity to head into the pits and rethink the entire direction of travel. For better or worse, they chose not to.
The most significant aspect of Duff’s appointment is not whether he succeeds or fails. It’s what the appointment says about how Bradford City increasingly view the manager’s role.
In the past, managerial departures often triggered an ideological reset. This feels different. City appear to have identified a way of playing, recruiting and developing that they believe can survive beyond the individual in the dugout.
For the first time in a long time, City appear to be acting as though the manager serves the model, rather than the model serving the manager.
Back in Malaysia, the track got drier. And with it, Lewis grew stronger. He climbed the field quickly. 15th. Then 11th. Then 9th. Then 5th. With two laps to go, it got even better. Hamilton leapt up to 3rd, and finished a challenging day on the podium. “I just kept my head down,” Hamilton reflected. Some drive, and some conviction when conviction was hardest.
In their own way, that is what Bradford City are doing with the expected appointment of Duff. They prepared for this season with a very clear strategy and invested a great deal of time and money in those preparations. Like Hamilton and the initial problem with tyres, sometimes events can test that wisdom (like losing your manager). Storm clouds can offer the temptation to change tact. But when you take a step back and reflect, that vision can still look like the right one. And instead of giving up, you double down.
It all makes for a very interesting next chapter. And it may have long-term implications. If Duff can pick up the baton and keep City moving forwards, the club really does have a blueprint that outlasts key personnel. Equally, if it doesn’t work, you could easily picture them abandoning this strategy and going back to treating managerial changes as an overhaul in overall thinking.
Many supporters have looked at the imminent arrival of Michael Duff and wished City would dive into the pits for a fresh set of tyres.
Instead, the club has seemingly stayed out.
They have looked at the squad, the style of play and the recruitment model they spent months building and decided the plan still makes sense.
Maybe they are wrong.
Maybe this is the moment they should have changed course.
But just like Hamilton in Malaysia, Bradford City have decided that if they believed in the strategy before the storm arrived, they should probably still believe in it afterwards.
The next few months will tell us whether that conviction is justified.
Categories: Opinion
Geoffrey Richmond: The man who changed how Bradford City saw itself
Metrics
Dream tie vs big opportunity?
Continuity coup or a Duff appointment? Assessing Bradford City’s new manager
Stick with what we have got Truman and Doyle, they know the club inside out why bring Duff in who lives 200 miles away .If he his successful at city he will jump ship like G A for a bigger club nearer home. We all saw how comfortable the players and staff were with the management team at Reading let’s stick with the tried and tested,and give these two lads a chance Promote from within it works at Liverpool why not Bradford . Truman as statedhe would like to be a manager give him and Doyler ago there here not 200 miles away down the road.
I’m sure Truman was considered, the club clearly rate him as a coach/player management liaison but that doesn’t mean those skills translate to being a manager. Rolling out the exact same team in the exact same formation for one game doesn’t tell us anything.
GA showing Smallwood the door despite him being his captain and first name on the team sheet in a promotion winning year, calling out our ‘star player’ Hump, facing up to the media in the tough times and presenting a calm confidence, these are a different set of skills
Its an interesting case study of the director of football role that hasn’t ever quite landed in England like it has in Europe. There is certainly logic and theory to it.
Particularly given the relatively unique make up of the squad and current playing style, I see Duff as a sensible appointment. It would cost us a heell of a lot more to change players for the manager rather than manager for the players.
Fingers crossed 🤞.
I didn’t want Jewell. No one did. I wasn’t fussed about Parkinson. However I did want Derek Adams. Let’s be honest, we have no idea what will happen. Let’s just give the new manager time
Interesting F1 analogy Jason (sign him up)!
There is quite a few comments that seem to favour a Truman Doyle appointment, & Its easy to see why. I like both, & they are both great with the players who they know inside out. I personally cant praise them enough, & the service MT has given our club over the years should never be underestimated in my opinion. There was recently a managerial vacancy at Hartlepools (since filled by Pete Wild), & I half expected Mark to apply for that, but I was so glad he didn’t (as far as I know anyway). Top of the new Manager`s to do list needs to be keeping MT & CD at the club. Their insight & player knowledge will be absolutely priceless. I think there may well come a time in the future when Mark and/or Colin do Manage Bradford City, but maybe not yet.
The more I have looked at Mr Duff, the more I like.I can see his qualities, & how they may well benefit our club/players/playing philosophy. His man management will be an area he has to get right though. Building a good bond & respect from our players doesn’t come overnight, but I believe will be vital if we are going to continue on the up. Maybe seeking a few tips from his good friend Mr Alexander could be a wise move regarding this.
Of course like many others, I wish we weren’t in this position in the first place. But we are, & under these pretty unique circumstance, I think our Board have made a very thoughtful decision in their appointment. There wont be any huge outpouring of general excitement at Mr Duff`s arrival, but in reality there wouldn’t be, whoever had been offered the job because deep down, we all still wish GA & CL were in the dugout. It’ll all take a little time for those bonds and trust to be established again, before a general acceptance turns into whole hearted support.
But if there’s 1 thing I’ve learnt over all these years supporting Bradford City, its patience 😉
Up the Bantams!
We dont have a ‘board’!
We have a single owner who rubs the club via a CEO.
There is no board of directors.
Thank you for an excellent article; I like the analogy.
Naturally, there’s been lots written about the Bradford City managerial vacancy; most of which should be taken with a pinch of salt.
I understand why some supporters will be disappointed if Michael Duff is named as our new manager. Speak to supporters of Swansea City and Huddersfield Town are they will probably be less kind in their thoughts on Duff as a manager than say the supporters of Cheltenham Town and Barnsley.
I do think that it can be a bit of a lottery when announcing a new manager. Supporters of Bradford City and Wigan Athletic will be positive about Paul Jewell, however those at Sheffield Wednesday and Derby County will be more negative about his managerial capability.
It’s the same for Phil Parkinson. Bradford City and Wrexham supporters will sing his praises whilst Hull City and Sunderland supporters will state that he was a failure.
If Duff performs well, most supporters will forget that he lives hundreds of miles from Bradford. But should he perform poorly, the distance topic will be used against him.
On the distance issue, personally I would prefer a manager to be based near to they club they are managing. However, I recently read that during his successful stint at Stoke City, Tony Pullis commuted hundreds of miles to his family home.
My final point is that if Michael Duff’s playing style is similar to Graham Alexander’s, I understand why Bradford City wish to appoint him as our next manager.
On time will tell whether if Michael Duff is a successful Bradford City manager or not.
Alexander’s move to Preston, which involved a financial compensation package, seemed to be done and dusted over a weekend. I wonder what is holding this particular deal up. When Alexander came here, it all seemed to go through rapidly the moment he lost his existing job. It’s fascinating to imagine what – if anything- is preventing Duff beginning immediately, if both parties are of a mind to make it happen. If any potential manager is overplaying his hand, we should walk away.
Nice analogy, Jason
I like to hope that City can be like Brentford
A well thought out long term plan which is not deflected by short term problems
Success has followed
Possibly Wakefield Trinity show what happens when you have good management structure and a plan
All must wish Duff the very best
As others have mentioned I love your analogy of the recruitment situation, it’s too easy in the current media driven environment to follow the same narrative regarding the base location of Duff. I think the club should be applauded for their decision and strategy regarding Duff’s appointment as it is clearly thought out with regards to keeping the club moving forward. Only time will tell if he is a successful manager for us but while he is manager he has my backing.
we are competing in the Grand Prix !
i’m interested that the club have given Michael Duff almost a 4 year contract. It sends the strongest signal that they are taking a long term perspective. I also note that they haven’t yet appointed an assistant manager- either there are still ongoing negotiations for his former no 2 that they didn’t want to hang around for, or maybe Mark Trueman will get the formal role he’s held before.
i know the headline message is continuity. But I think Graham Alexander’s least commented on quality was his openness to acknowledging mistakes, and his willingness to learn- and improve as he did. Remember that dark February in 2024 when we lost so heavily, and GA was pilloried for spending several matches in the press box? He was clearly trying to get his head clear on what was going wrong. I think he left us as a much better manager than when he arrived. And he tore up plenty of his own established ways of setting up his team in the process.
So my biggest hope for Michael Duff is not that he sticks like glue to the current approach- but he learns and grows too.
is it time to dig out that old term never used, Bradford City Progressivism?
I remember years ago watching a Copa90 video about the Superclásico (Boca v River Plate). They spoke about the difference in style and attitude between the two clubs, with Boca being the more industrious of the two — even having the mantra of “making the shirt sweat”.
I remember it reminding me of City and what we, as a fanbase, value from our players. After both the Parky and Alexander eras, I just think there’s something about this club that is suited to the gritty, streetwise, in-your-face side of the game.
I’m glad we’ve gone for continuity and found somebody who fits the club’s identity. It feels like we’ve figured ourselves out a little bit.
A great analogy Jason. Duff is as near to Alexander as we are going to get to maintain continuity. We were fishing in a fairly small pond anyway. There are certainly no promises of success whoever we gave the job to so lets all get right behind the guy.
Let me share the recent history of Inter Milan. Inter is the other team I support, and they’ve been doing this for a bit. Please bear with me for this one will be slightly long.
Way back (2017), Inter had hired Spalletti. Spalletti played the 4-2-3-1 (played that most of his career). After 2 years in charge, he got the team to qualify for the Champions League, but didn’t challenge for the title. Inter then swerved, let him go, and hired Conte instead (2019).
Conte plays a 3-5-2. Inter had to undergo a squal overhaul to suit his needs. Back then, the chinese owners were strong, and backed him completely. Conte led Inter to a title in 2020-21) Then when Covid (2020) hit, the chinese owners were hit hard, and couldn’t invest in the club anymore. Conte saw the writing on the wall, and left.
Here (start of 2021 season), the owners had to make a decision. Either go for an established manager (Allegri, Mourinho etc.), but they played with a 4 man backline. This meant another overhaul of the squad, which the owners couldn’t afford. Either this, or hire a manager who played the same formation.
They chose the latter. Simone Inzaghi had overachieved at Lazio for many years, played the 3-5-2, and his contract had just run out. While he was close to renewing, Inter mgnmt contacted him before he did, and offered him the position.
This was purely about saving money (no manager compensation, no squad overhaul). Inzaghi took Inter to the next level (Two Champions League Finals, A Scudetto) while selling their best players every year, and on a fraction of the budget of other european heavyweights.
After Inzaghi left (2025) for the monies of Arabia, Inter again had a deciion to make. This time though, their finances were in order, and they could afford a squad overhaul. They made an approach for Cesc, but got rebuffed, and moved to Chivu (managed Inter youth teams, rich playing history at Inter, earned a mark saving Parma from relegation in 6 months etc.).
Crucially, while they hired Chivu, they retained the tactical coach who worked under Inzaghi. Yet another decision to continue with what’s worked, rather than changing things.
I’ve been following this development/ trend at Inter for years. If it’s working, I am well aware of the benefits of continuing with a formation, an identity; rather than tearing it up to chase a name.
It doesn’t mean Duff will be a success. There’s no guarantee for that, but, it’s the better option over changing tactics, formation, expensive squad overhaul; especially when your budget is limited.